{"schema_version": 1, "scope": {"worlds": 20, "architectures": 7, "value_systems": 6, "rows": 140, "runs_per_world_architecture": 8000, "dynamic_trajectories": 1120000, "years": 300, "step_years": 5, "data_kind": "aggregate outputs; not individual trajectory logs"}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "parameter_definitions": [{"id": "s0", "name": {"plain": "Starting synthetic share", "technical": "Initial synthetic population share"}, "unit": "fraction", "sampling": {"distribution": "fixed baseline; see demographic adjustment equations in model code"}}, {"id": "syn_g", "name": {"plain": "Baseline synthetic population growth", "technical": "Baseline annualized synthetic net growth"}, "unit": "annualized baseline rate", "sampling": {"distribution": "fixed baseline; see demographic adjustment equations in model code"}}, {"id": "org_g", "name": {"plain": "Baseline human/organic population growth", "technical": "Baseline annualized organic net growth"}, "unit": "annualized baseline rate", "sampling": {"distribution": "fixed baseline; see demographic adjustment equations in model code"}}, {"id": "scarcity", "name": {"plain": "Pressure from scarce resources", "technical": "Resource scarcity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 14}}, {"id": "tech", "name": {"plain": "Technology level", "technical": "Technology intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 14}}, {"id": "prod", "name": {"plain": "Synthetic productivity advantage", "technical": "Synthetic productivity advantage intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "returns", "name": {"plain": "Pressure from enduring wealth advantages", "technical": "Durable-capital concentration pressure"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "hom", "name": {"plain": "Preference for staying within one’s own population", "technical": "Cross-species homophily"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 12}}, {"id": "attacks", "name": {"plain": "Attacks on minds", "technical": "Cognitive attack intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "rogue", "name": {"plain": "Pressure from illegal copying", "technical": "Illicit replication intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "disaster", "name": {"plain": "Disaster pressure", "technical": "Disaster intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "ext", "name": {"plain": "Pressure from outside conflict", "technical": "External threat intensity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "capacity", "name": {"plain": "Ability to run public institutions", "technical": "Institutional capacity"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 16}}, {"id": "private", "name": {"plain": "Dependence on concentrated private infrastructure", "technical": "Private concentration pressure"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 12}}, {"id": "planets", "name": {"plain": "Demand from settlement across worlds", "technical": "Interplanetary load"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 10}}, {"id": "abundance", "name": {"plain": "Resource abundance", "technical": "Abundance"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 14}}, {"id": "polar", "name": {"plain": "Political division", "technical": "Polarization"}, "unit": "assumed 0–1 index", "sampling": {"distribution": "Beta", "mean": "scenario value clipped to [0.02, 0.98]", "concentration": 12}}], "shared_assumptions": {"civic_culture": "Beta concentration 10; mean .72 when scenario polar < .5, otherwise .55", "behavioral_sensitivities": "Six sensitivities independently Uniform(.65,1.35): contact, grievance, capture, resilience, cognitive, economic", "implementation": "clip(.45 + .55 * capacity - architecture complexity * (1-capacity) * Uniform(.20,.65))", "pairing_limit": "Common seed schedules and predrawn exogenous shocks improve comparability, but conditional random calls can disrupt perfect later pairing.", "scoring": "sum(weight * avg_metric) - .22*(1-no_catastrophic_failure) - .08*bifurcation_rate - .05*private_sovereignty_rate", "score_note": "All six value systems share failure penalties and the same outcome definitions. They do not span every plausible moral theory.", "aggregation": "Arithmetic means across equally weighted worlds; mean value score also gives equal weight to all six value systems.", "averaging": "State averages include zeros after collapse. Parameter indices are assumptions, not event probabilities."}, "architectures": [{"id": "PULSE", "name": {"plain": "PULSE", "technical": "PULSE"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.96, "checks": 0.92, "voice": 0.88, "group": 0.95, "integ": 0.92, "cog": 0.95, "resil": 0.95, "private": 0.72, "adapt": 0.78, "grid": 0.22, "complexity": 0.46, "salience": 0.28, "restore": 0.96, "federal": 0.86, "techgov": 0.25, "emergency": 0.18, "innovation": 0.8, "equality": 0.82}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7911375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.62710625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.56808125, "domination_rate": 0.00019375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.184925, "bifurcation_rate": 0.02800625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0002, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0094, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0096875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.16235625, "avg_liberty": 0.7251834154781017, "avg_individuality": 0.7601232701413723, "avg_integration": 0.5941575416339632, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6461032362619623, "avg_resilience": 0.6101207517859573, "avg_prosperity": 0.2993480343606372, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8549366794485689, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8040319707474637, "avg_trust": 0.5786653073403762, "avg_inequality": 0.5841030925692925, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9331168648747181, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.028828699461186165, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5948073880417107, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5986840321979837, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5939216431102826, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5000665472756748, "score_Stability-first": 0.5701979491663176, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6171201985638768}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "name": {"plain": "Liberal democracy with constitutional rights", "technical": "Liberal constitutional democracy"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.88, "checks": 0.84, "voice": 0.88, "group": 0.52, "integ": 0.34, "cog": 0.74, "resil": 0.58, "private": 0.6, "adapt": 0.86, "grid": 0.18, "complexity": 0.22, "salience": 0.08, "restore": 0.38, "federal": 0.72, "techgov": 0.2, "emergency": 0.22, "innovation": 0.8, "equality": 0.68}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.81725625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6309125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.28490624999999997, "domination_rate": 0.00061875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1961875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.02998125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00026250000000000004, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01941875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0184625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1655375, "avg_liberty": 0.7008618844069413, "avg_individuality": 0.6799542422667051, "avg_integration": 0.42781404450161725, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6600833644280469, "avg_resilience": 0.4143254930382654, "avg_prosperity": 0.30639401977306985, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8036407037075224, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8765348147169468, "avg_trust": 0.5554914767804935, "avg_inequality": 0.5759368197200021, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9326151976284438, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.024874314073270717, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5289109366950376, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5549456147309214, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.56059057090883, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.45305488560957247, "score_Stability-first": 0.4992300274815141, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5517939095993905}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Majoritarian democracy", "name": {"plain": "Majority rule with fewer group protections", "technical": "Majoritarian democracy"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.7, "checks": 0.56, "voice": 0.86, "group": 0.2, "integ": 0.22, "cog": 0.58, "resil": 0.48, "private": 0.48, "adapt": 0.9, "grid": 0.07, "complexity": 0.12, "salience": 0.1, "restore": 0.22, "federal": 0.58, "techgov": 0.18, "emergency": 0.36, "innovation": 0.82, "equality": 0.55}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.77853125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5346062500000001, "free_integrated_rate": 0.07473125, "domination_rate": 0.0248, "authoritarian_rate": 0.257225, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0364, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0014, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.02046875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.061475, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.16278125, "avg_liberty": 0.5784077898756756, "avg_individuality": 0.5989003723547943, "avg_integration": 0.3774949186159848, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6264450217125749, "avg_resilience": 0.353553162646478, "avg_prosperity": 0.30402726201601704, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6959333719188596, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8870727447938107, "avg_trust": 0.5147821300892867, "avg_inequality": 0.5456703432889334, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9316004136935941, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.03004216743919162, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4380597912641335, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45849181733953165, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4804192143644791, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38652730873324503, "score_Stability-first": 0.4226889332702809, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4544629286712295}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Strict consociational parity", "name": {"plain": "Strict equal power for both populations", "technical": "Strict consociational parity"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.84, "checks": 0.84, "voice": 0.82, "group": 0.99, "integ": 0.28, "cog": 0.78, "resil": 0.68, "private": 0.6, "adapt": 0.6, "grid": 0.5, "complexity": 0.42, "salience": 0.82, "restore": 0.65, "federal": 0.7, "techgov": 0.2, "emergency": 0.24, "innovation": 0.7, "equality": 0.75}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.595575, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.45003125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.1391625, "domination_rate": 0.0001625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.19581875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.08081875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0009062499999999999, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01401875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.02513125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.14484375, "avg_liberty": 0.5856318125809018, "avg_individuality": 0.6008332579697058, "avg_integration": 0.3388264271471319, "avg_legitimacy": 0.47570224365299224, "avg_resilience": 0.4002429277090984, "avg_prosperity": 0.23192124171422873, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7636015843502125, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5135183559714346, "avg_trust": 0.4328250871706109, "avg_inequality": 0.508206147409012, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9406988721079602, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.020317541607375655, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.38966894775416966, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4096656868993778, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3863409621669529, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.30771434743402404, "score_Stability-first": 0.3528851963954299, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4171201393094916}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Species-separated federalism", "name": {"plain": "Separate self-government for each population", "technical": "Species-separated federalism"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.82, "checks": 0.78, "voice": 0.82, "group": 0.92, "integ": 0.06, "cog": 0.78, "resil": 0.78, "private": 0.6, "adapt": 0.72, "grid": 0.32, "complexity": 0.38, "salience": 0.92, "restore": 0.58, "federal": 0.95, "techgov": 0.18, "emergency": 0.24, "innovation": 0.68, "equality": 0.72}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.6813875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5078, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0490125, "domination_rate": 0.00043750000000000006, "authoritarian_rate": 0.21189375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.116275, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00080625, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01526875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.04021875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.15305, "avg_liberty": 0.6079183034450737, "avg_individuality": 0.6284182081434517, "avg_integration": 0.29341774186923875, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5351023840965162, "avg_resilience": 0.4581471559252779, "avg_prosperity": 0.25991255885522535, "avg_anti_domination": 0.796765824420885, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6632788309502153, "avg_trust": 0.4583746487818664, "avg_inequality": 0.5349401998881265, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9378094941929073, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.021495591612065965, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4308407967829745, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45527641171138233, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4400567165448315, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.36071469634683906, "score_Stability-first": 0.40888755706733915, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45468809957735984}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "name": {"plain": "Rule led by technical guardians", "technical": "Technocratic guardian governance"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.64, "checks": 0.52, "voice": 0.32, "group": 0.58, "integ": 0.48, "cog": 0.84, "resil": 0.9, "private": 0.78, "adapt": 0.92, "grid": 0.05, "complexity": 0.34, "salience": 0.12, "restore": 0.9, "federal": 0.7, "techgov": 0.92, "emergency": 0.48, "innovation": 0.92, "equality": 0.62}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.66853125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.340775, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0584625, "domination_rate": 0.00163125, "authoritarian_rate": 0.42534375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0316375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00019375, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01108125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0478375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.15354375, "avg_liberty": 0.49764332876773293, "avg_individuality": 0.669021737378918, "avg_integration": 0.423700930254449, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4556727583049797, "avg_resilience": 0.5361000763061534, "avg_prosperity": 0.29175544544954807, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7272273729446721, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8321507794032441, "avg_trust": 0.4120212445503422, "avg_inequality": 0.5210566926346487, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9299423176101687, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.02693615154834653, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.40687036766854395, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.40593400778345845, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4003864305636776, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3576905345001801, "score_Stability-first": 0.40355222975460636, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4265332483367864}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}, {"id": "Minimal-rights market order", "name": {"plain": "A market order with fewer public safeguards", "technical": "Minimal-rights market order"}, "parameters": {"rights": 0.72, "checks": 0.54, "voice": 0.74, "group": 0.28, "integ": 0.16, "cog": 0.66, "resil": 0.46, "private": 0.2, "adapt": 0.95, "grid": 0.05, "complexity": 0.08, "salience": 0.08, "restore": 0.24, "federal": 0.62, "techgov": 0.12, "emergency": 0.3, "innovation": 0.96, "equality": 0.38}, "baseline_aggregate": {"n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.76938125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.49745, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0782125, "domination_rate": 0.015487500000000001, "authoritarian_rate": 0.29958125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0363875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00055625, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.02041875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.06910625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1621875, "avg_liberty": 0.5883169978898413, "avg_individuality": 0.6146138718246186, "avg_integration": 0.3564026116409143, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5948018941897489, "avg_resilience": 0.3342205340633556, "avg_prosperity": 0.29805932107242333, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6965284915876795, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8846310257010278, "avg_trust": 0.4888971650778578, "avg_inequality": 0.5181390173753644, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9326422822559561, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.029322149947846574, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4246134451836536, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4489561051582033, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4623686624816548, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3704645885763904, "score_Stability-first": 0.4029170258346067, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4451839595005361}, "parameter_status": {"plain": "Assigned model settings, not measured scores for real governments.", "technical": "Stylized architecture parameterization; no empirical institutional calibration is claimed."}}], "value_systems": [{"id": "PULSE-aligned", "name": {"plain": "PULSE’s priorities", "technical": "PULSE-aligned"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.17, "individuality": 0.17, "integration": 0.12, "anti_domination": 0.15, "legitimacy": 0.08, "resilience": 0.13, "prosperity": 0.07, "governance_eff": 0.05, "trust": 0.03, "inequality": 0.03}}, {"id": "Classical-liberal", "name": {"plain": "Individual liberty first", "technical": "Classical-liberal"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.28, "individuality": 0.18, "integration": 0.03, "anti_domination": 0.14, "legitimacy": 0.08, "resilience": 0.08, "prosperity": 0.1, "governance_eff": 0.05, "trust": 0.02, "inequality": 0.04}}, {"id": "Procedural-democratic", "name": {"plain": "Democratic legitimacy first", "technical": "Procedural-democratic"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.16, "individuality": 0.1, "integration": 0.07, "anti_domination": 0.12, "legitimacy": 0.23, "resilience": 0.07, "prosperity": 0.06, "governance_eff": 0.1, "trust": 0.05, "inequality": 0.04}}, {"id": "Capability-utilitarian", "name": {"plain": "Capabilities and prosperity first", "technical": "Capability-utilitarian"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.1, "individuality": 0.08, "integration": 0.05, "anti_domination": 0.08, "legitimacy": 0.05, "resilience": 0.18, "prosperity": 0.28, "governance_eff": 0.1, "trust": 0.03, "inequality": 0.05}}, {"id": "Stability-first", "name": {"plain": "Stability and resilience first", "technical": "Stability-first"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.08, "individuality": 0.07, "integration": 0.08, "anti_domination": 0.12, "legitimacy": 0.12, "resilience": 0.27, "prosperity": 0.08, "governance_eff": 0.1, "trust": 0.04, "inequality": 0.04}}, {"id": "Individuality-first", "name": {"plain": "Individual identity and agency first", "technical": "Individuality-first"}, "weights": {"liberty": 0.18, "individuality": 0.3, "integration": 0.1, "anti_domination": 0.14, "legitimacy": 0.05, "resilience": 0.08, "prosperity": 0.04, "governance_eff": 0.03, "trust": 0.04, "inequality": 0.04}}], "metric_definitions": {"survival_rate": {"plain": "Share of runs without modeled constitutional collapse. Other serious failures may still occur.", "technical": "Fraction with no collapse flag; not equivalent to no catastrophic failure."}, "no_catastrophic_failure": {"plain": "Share without modeled collapse, unrecovered population loss, domination, authoritarian capture or failure to protect individuality.", "technical": "Complement of the union of collapse, unrecovered species loss, domination, authoritarian capture and individuality-failure flags."}, "free_integrated_rate": {"plain": "Share that avoids major failures and deep social separation, while passing the model’s freedom, individuality, cooperation, protection and legitimacy tests.", "technical": "No catastrophic failure or bifurcation, with time-averaged liberty > .65, individuality > .70, integration > .50, anti-domination > .70 and legitimacy > .50."}, "bifurcation_rate": {"plain": "Share flagged for a lasting split into divided populations.", "technical": "Integration < .36 and cleavage > .52 in at least three accumulated counter periods after the first fifth of the horizon, while active; the counter decays rather than resetting when the condition is false."}, "avg_inequality": {"plain": "Despite its file name, higher values mean more equality.", "technical": "Time-averaged 1 − inequality; a higher value indicates lower inequality."}, "avg_prosperity": {"plain": "A scaled prosperity score. It is not dollars, GDP or a growth percentage.", "technical": "Average log(prosperity + 1) / log(21), clipped to [0,1], with zero after collapse."}, "avg_governance_eff": {"plain": "The model’s score for getting governing work done.", "technical": "Normalized governance-efficiency state, averaged with zero post-collapse."}, "domination_rate": {"plain": "Share flagged for one population dominating the other.", "technical": "Accumulated domination flag from the model’s anti-domination, exclusion and cleavage conditions."}, "authoritarian_rate": {"plain": "Share flagged for authoritarian capture.", "technical": "Aggregate authoritarian-event flag rate."}, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": {"plain": "Share flagged for population loss without recovery.", "technical": "Aggregate unrecovered species-loss flag rate."}}, "worlds": [{"id": "world-01", "source_scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "name": {"plain": "Gradual emergence", "technical": "Gradual emergence"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.08, "syn_g": 0.014, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.28, "tech": 0.45, "prod": 0.25, "returns": 0.25, "hom": 0.35, "attacks": 0.18, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.12, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.35, "planets": 0.05, "abundance": 0.45, "polar": 0.3}, "focus_parameters": ["s0", "syn_g"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.829375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.677625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.668625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.170625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00325, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.002375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1225, "avg_liberty": 0.7588129643523078, "avg_individuality": 0.8052016342423933, "avg_integration": 0.6393796495370814, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6839550097862487, "avg_resilience": 0.6484232827632768, "avg_prosperity": 0.28192944017161314, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8844196875973696, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8418906373616205, "avg_trust": 0.6263438524015089, "avg_inequality": 0.6901770765045555, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8320886109057485, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010900240814762619, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.644685140934556, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6464932693294377, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6446230635708718, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5394399024274549, "score_Stability-first": 0.6199805296463714, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6702473920678035}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.84225, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6785, "free_integrated_rate": 0.36825, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1795, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00675, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0065, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12375, "avg_liberty": 0.7255882023694239, "avg_individuality": 0.7265499949420304, "avg_integration": 0.4604746625346803, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6904270037756738, "avg_resilience": 0.4343370287429783, "avg_prosperity": 0.2871723870407872, "avg_anti_domination": 0.830017926562163, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9039005180899952, "avg_trust": 0.5953737727712102, "avg_inequality": 0.6761169676440772, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8293952418313004, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008293446338815926, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5710329312798879, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5960759867190055, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6034900546943819, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4845453841922918, "score_Stability-first": 0.5389613906282891, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5988227040104411}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.803, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.491875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.12125, "domination_rate": 0.177625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.244375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.017625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12, "avg_liberty": 0.5898495035157216, "avg_individuality": 0.6436600395377797, "avg_integration": 0.4064159025220914, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6499271852016709, "avg_resilience": 0.3689447382316027, "avg_prosperity": 0.2850792684164501, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7260675567400304, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8995117374596702, "avg_trust": 0.5490065329747394, "avg_inequality": 0.6409329283899143, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8261484250302672, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010131287755286917, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.45614547442206743, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.47465181850485116, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4979546024095275, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.39426307663298454, "score_Stability-first": 0.4380294772800757, "score_Individuality-first": 0.47774251032362314}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.649625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.50525, "free_integrated_rate": 0.1575, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.18925, "bifurcation_rate": 0.002125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.005875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1105, "avg_liberty": 0.620372151873079, "avg_individuality": 0.6565083123909674, "avg_integration": 0.37332292966643776, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5122884879472334, "avg_resilience": 0.4288570635004773, "avg_prosperity": 0.22301458705436536, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8017097898024579, "avg_governance_eff": 0.552321191029484, "avg_trust": 0.47788609858637576, "avg_inequality": 0.6100561823082558, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8484808943751015, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.006675752342512091, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4457097453181887, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4654688888539588, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4429890486124913, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35367010122472614, "score_Stability-first": 0.4064983661687038, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4781070445196765}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.724875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.561375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.023625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.20075, "bifurcation_rate": 0.008125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00575, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.008375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11525, "avg_liberty": 0.6388777650159315, "avg_individuality": 0.6819747227701956, "avg_integration": 0.3220982085658849, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5706257393912079, "avg_resilience": 0.4868335575277806, "avg_prosperity": 0.24809789298292667, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8305258768359072, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7011548290977166, "avg_trust": 0.50099153175164, "avg_inequality": 0.6370531694833623, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8414558391992341, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.0070921664763985036, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4861324461075828, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5103965252381644, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4963357234420756, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.406471859594645, "score_Stability-first": 0.46253716535801953, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5148846783609733}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7015, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.36675, "free_integrated_rate": 0.06825, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.42675, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.004125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.010875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.114625, "avg_liberty": 0.5201696865100836, "avg_individuality": 0.7139226016840234, "avg_integration": 0.45872924936015136, "avg_legitimacy": 0.47869192486000145, "avg_resilience": 0.5672126296582305, "avg_prosperity": 0.27566424430914793, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7568209940408486, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8568989804392959, "avg_trust": 0.4471452980287215, "avg_inequality": 0.6181895334319931, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8233679336221414, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009018641867200163, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4451858349341403, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4423096222846633, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4373526024851989, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3865305104214395, "score_Stability-first": 0.4407368881104148, "score_Individuality-first": 0.46897872723838796}, {"scenario": "01 Gradual emergence", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.794, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.509125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.093, "domination_rate": 0.069375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2885, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00725, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.018, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.119625, "avg_liberty": 0.6056385251159306, "avg_individuality": 0.6602453360749103, "avg_integration": 0.3849259894220439, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6178513903509129, "avg_resilience": 0.34894103275832344, "avg_prosperity": 0.28042924583900525, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7266147750892809, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8973874383923878, "avg_trust": 0.5226916979070446, "avg_inequality": 0.6128108972056695, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8285618726114768, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009875833048191035, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4557160338648666, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4788962559197316, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.49278600134324746, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3910186447615295, "score_Stability-first": 0.43058304069672004, "score_Individuality-first": 0.48165145172609625}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.644685140934556, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5710329312798879, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4861324461075828, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.45614547442206743, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4557160338648666, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4457097453181887, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4451858349341403, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6464932693294377, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5960759867190055, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5103965252381644, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4788962559197316, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.47465181850485116, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4654688888539588, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4423096222846633, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6446230635708718, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6034900546943819, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4979546024095275, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4963357234420756, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.49278600134324746, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4429890486124913, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4373526024851989, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5394399024274549, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4845453841922918, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.406471859594645, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.39426307663298454, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3910186447615295, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3865305104214395, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.35367010122472614, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6199805296463714, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5389613906282891, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.46253716535801953, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4407368881104148, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4380294772800757, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.43058304069672004, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4064983661687038, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6702473920678035, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5988227040104411, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5148846783609733, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.48165145172609625, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4781070445196765, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.47774251032362314, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.46897872723838796, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 66.86% of these modeled runs. A gradual starting point still becomes a demanding long-run test as population shares change. It does not assume that present-day AI is a person.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 66.86% of these modeled runs. A gradual starting point still becomes a demanding long-run test as population shares change. It does not assume that present-day AI is a person."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-02", "source_scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "name": {"plain": "Rapid synthetic growth", "technical": "Rapid synthetic growth"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.1, "syn_g": 0.045, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.68, "prod": 0.5, "returns": 0.35, "hom": 0.38, "attacks": 0.24, "rogue": 0.22, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.14, "capacity": 0.8, "private": 0.4, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.55, "polar": 0.36}, "focus_parameters": ["syn_g", "tech"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.814875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.651125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.63075, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.171, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.017625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.003625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.120125, "avg_liberty": 0.7409682801201117, "avg_individuality": 0.7775246411961982, "avg_integration": 0.6046620325109668, "avg_legitimacy": 0.663986336074833, "avg_resilience": 0.626473520072721, "avg_prosperity": 0.30832725168660613, "avg_anti_domination": 0.86281960595173, "avg_governance_eff": 0.822497798754218, "avg_trust": 0.5940799896684548, "avg_inequality": 0.5955991928465298, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9995120379074968, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.03390105922962516, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6163223189445115, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6204976307629244, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6162569698050171, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5209432895062769, "score_Stability-first": 0.592182340667992, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6390425206050678}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.83425, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.641625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.251625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.184125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.036625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.008, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121875, "avg_liberty": 0.7133303711001717, "avg_individuality": 0.6896314685848448, "avg_integration": 0.4308847591989785, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6744161851322015, "avg_resilience": 0.42298008420716054, "avg_prosperity": 0.3143451323502609, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7919313564234565, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8907584510406309, "avg_trust": 0.567422219259139, "avg_inequality": 0.5842098992373133, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9997074396301764, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.025902948841645953, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5401586384427991, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5672715786174555, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5738175906016911, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.46571266918630516, "score_Stability-first": 0.5113939813794256, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5632963327509364}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.796625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.539375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0405, "domination_rate": 0.026375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.249625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0395, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.04225, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11975, "avg_liberty": 0.5892988531421429, "avg_individuality": 0.6063140557836222, "avg_integration": 0.37773903051470736, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6385499789206209, "avg_resilience": 0.3608347954847902, "avg_prosperity": 0.31197288367308074, "avg_anti_domination": 0.663612641681769, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8967179506664786, "avg_trust": 0.5249481869938222, "avg_inequality": 0.5533695022332494, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9997099466943603, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.03155758928632168, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.44376332622533454, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.46561836135401224, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.48851425958067884, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3953523579870619, "score_Stability-first": 0.4298747571801589, "score_Individuality-first": 0.46057762720840556}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.624, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.46775, "free_integrated_rate": 0.093375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.190125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.010875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.025375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10775, "avg_liberty": 0.5999174435569491, "avg_individuality": 0.6141806671348152, "avg_integration": 0.34183717242516376, "avg_legitimacy": 0.49042152371854497, "avg_resilience": 0.4107185589608875, "avg_prosperity": 0.23927421297781057, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7751049795751027, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5280189835006223, "avg_trust": 0.44555267016097866, "avg_inequality": 0.5209549205110098, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9997060989899026, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.020918383710725408, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4104903928109215, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4315030439043086, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.40820248834111483, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3279248756268626, "score_Stability-first": 0.3737293463078501, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4384231569175351}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.708375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.523375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.010375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.205, "bifurcation_rate": 0.029, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.027875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.014125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1135, "avg_liberty": 0.6215145144153272, "avg_individuality": 0.6403995510542074, "avg_integration": 0.29331590658645185, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5499876569340781, "avg_resilience": 0.4686290779442727, "avg_prosperity": 0.2676656428351865, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8034307105022147, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6774822581843599, "avg_trust": 0.47023845211519144, "avg_inequality": 0.5463781861625262, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9996821164720395, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.02220421044621004, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4510904062390217, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4767881723657624, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.46172498712493554, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38111945325591234, "score_Stability-first": 0.4296031001676052, "score_Individuality-first": 0.47531233611226903}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.692125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.34925, "free_integrated_rate": 0.043125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4235, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.02125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.022, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.114375, "avg_liberty": 0.5083974525203909, "avg_individuality": 0.6824616531151194, "avg_integration": 0.4283160604010133, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4674559761484843, "avg_resilience": 0.5499192736090431, "avg_prosperity": 0.3007095908716797, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7156567691172144, "avg_governance_eff": 0.847243741690364, "avg_trust": 0.42255780549735666, "avg_inequality": 0.5311057647611447, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.999578430078729, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.028145064732748002, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4189052397880857, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4185593666075528, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4134039883903463, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37142337212381316, "score_Stability-first": 0.41689381430720707, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43903717049678326}, {"scenario": "02 Rapid synthetic growth", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.785875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.502125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.037375, "domination_rate": 0.00725, "authoritarian_rate": 0.293625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.039, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.048375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.118875, "avg_liberty": 0.5988111754054399, "avg_individuality": 0.6217663429184258, "avg_integration": 0.35606211797359283, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6057534968514997, "avg_resilience": 0.3407377919449279, "avg_prosperity": 0.3055631605429901, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6666886570478727, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8925955422251791, "avg_trust": 0.4980453706817591, "avg_inequality": 0.5248425484010816, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9997172635105174, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.030770932687110963, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4301184594517834, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4558908519837004, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.47000517349782767, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37880932854425153, "score_Stability-first": 0.4096533935969384, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45114864588252623}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6163223189445115, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5401586384427991, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4510904062390217, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44376332622533454, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4301184594517834, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4189052397880857, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4104903928109215, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6204976307629244, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5672715786174555, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4767881723657624, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46561836135401224, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4558908519837004, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4315030439043086, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4185593666075528, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6162569698050171, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5738175906016911, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.48851425958067884, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.47000517349782767, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.46172498712493554, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4134039883903463, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.40820248834111483, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5209432895062769, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.46571266918630516, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3953523579870619, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.38111945325591234, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.37880932854425153, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.37142337212381316, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3279248756268626, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.592182340667992, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5113939813794256, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4298747571801589, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4296031001676052, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.41689381430720707, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4096533935969384, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3737293463078501, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6390425206050678, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5632963327509364, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.47531233611226903, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46057762720840556, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45114864588252623, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.43903717049678326, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4384231569175351, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 63.08% of these modeled runs. Fast growth tests representation and shared institutions. Growth rates are model inputs, not estimates of how conscious synthetic persons would reproduce.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 63.08% of these modeled runs. Fast growth tests representation and shared institutions. Growth rates are model inputs, not estimates of how conscious synthetic persons would reproduce."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-03", "source_scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "name": {"plain": "Synthetic persons begin in the majority", "technical": "Synthetic demographic majority"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.55, "syn_g": 0.018, "org_g": -0.001, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.62, "prod": 0.45, "returns": 0.35, "hom": 0.4, "attacks": 0.24, "rogue": 0.14, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.15, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.38, "planets": 0.1, "abundance": 0.55, "polar": 0.38}, "focus_parameters": ["s0", "org_g"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.81875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.65075, "free_integrated_rate": 0.627625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.177, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01775, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.004, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121625, "avg_liberty": 0.750305816554102, "avg_individuality": 0.7866434510417177, "avg_integration": 0.5983785521497185, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6703918960730639, "avg_resilience": 0.634746683353675, "avg_prosperity": 0.3022999019556623, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8654210186026264, "avg_governance_eff": 0.825276069760862, "avg_trust": 0.5965745531414728, "avg_inequality": 0.5946218915667366, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9972835731100391, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.018624615476623828, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6203740650276582, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6255779957547645, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6205169049803546, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.522853575338011, "score_Stability-first": 0.5961634022566685, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6440073455429213}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.835875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.639375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.220875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.189875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.036375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.009625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.123375, "avg_liberty": 0.7201803105212368, "avg_individuality": 0.6985445137195563, "avg_integration": 0.42011350068350817, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6790008492188843, "avg_resilience": 0.42667179168024816, "avg_prosperity": 0.30820589323242215, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7914416028267719, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8916835873043283, "avg_trust": 0.5678846749257203, "avg_inequality": 0.5824479538266186, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9975390096331914, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01422724370924621, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5414015522369707, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5699404204436881, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5754868234041013, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.46523100714800786, "score_Stability-first": 0.5122467341950143, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5658173187676727}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7965, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.554, "free_integrated_rate": 0.039125, "domination_rate": 0.005625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.249, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0015, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.037, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.043, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121, "avg_liberty": 0.5932076272947504, "avg_individuality": 0.6126798377360286, "avg_integration": 0.3653082650363653, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6407692532319769, "avg_resilience": 0.3626300399129859, "avg_prosperity": 0.30533972773039164, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6586972269106842, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8942311868641366, "avg_trust": 0.5230837671812908, "avg_inequality": 0.5497618173768314, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.997519437159459, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.017337764498989792, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.44607659816452316, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.46928698976014416, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4912056443642293, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3964670573341703, "score_Stability-first": 0.4319390687088067, "score_Individuality-first": 0.46409297645709835}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.627, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.465875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.077875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1935, "bifurcation_rate": 0.017375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.027375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.009375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10825, "avg_liberty": 0.6066300608292685, "avg_individuality": 0.6228948958190519, "avg_integration": 0.3333998090467274, "avg_legitimacy": 0.49443211037063545, "avg_resilience": 0.41530830307987454, "avg_prosperity": 0.23450733760937784, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7772679272176838, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5282487325112195, "avg_trust": 0.44614734645441984, "avg_inequality": 0.5191250540871117, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9979265704736774, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011483312515668257, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.41205067930297223, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4342298549166145, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4098215868087086, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.32775322333084717, "score_Stability-first": 0.3748411349211112, "score_Individuality-first": 0.44110679167642697}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.712125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5255, "free_integrated_rate": 0.006375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.207625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.04625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.029, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.014625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.114875, "avg_liberty": 0.6295856214865427, "avg_individuality": 0.6506081107435288, "avg_integration": 0.283562096749166, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5552265019307039, "avg_resilience": 0.47447210815825197, "avg_prosperity": 0.26282054410126704, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8068910692525162, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6795334805332159, "avg_trust": 0.47154182080377804, "avg_inequality": 0.5458064718316087, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9977582497814097, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012190343076960932, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4535981015847297, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.48067275908113827, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4644278592229337, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3817925845681869, "score_Stability-first": 0.4317388862424566, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4790506560955632}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.697, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.35875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.050375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.419875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.02125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.021875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.115, "avg_liberty": 0.514425587595179, "avg_individuality": 0.6917273564774633, "avg_integration": 0.4197408017092495, "avg_legitimacy": 0.47035013505440687, "avg_resilience": 0.5560305667786289, "avg_prosperity": 0.2953681920862038, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7157085667956467, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8482434321632891, "avg_trust": 0.422033360045613, "avg_inequality": 0.5297202847758442, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9972284271329733, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.015455743060632082, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4232187206012228, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4239254376506354, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.41758229866993324, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37419693352032934, "score_Stability-first": 0.4210284677260965, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4445152207689025}, {"scenario": "03 Synthetic demographic majority", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7865, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.50725, "free_integrated_rate": 0.03425, "domination_rate": 0.004125, "authoritarian_rate": 0.295875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.036875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.051, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1205, "avg_liberty": 0.6024690153953254, "avg_individuality": 0.6284790229503663, "avg_integration": 0.3437622895942653, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6076538342893171, "avg_resilience": 0.34248534679967363, "avg_prosperity": 0.2991898784737103, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6623780563434617, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8903957945889358, "avg_trust": 0.49606895229533826, "avg_inequality": 0.5211233912116816, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9975782347668612, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01690574183263371, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4304786030765187, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45757457177598065, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4706603833841731, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37797962006213587, "score_Stability-first": 0.4097243699946093, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45274096867911656}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6203740650276582, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5414015522369707, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4535981015847297, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44607659816452316, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4304786030765187, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4232187206012228, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.41205067930297223, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6255779957547645, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5699404204436881, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.48067275908113827, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46928698976014416, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45757457177598065, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4342298549166145, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4239254376506354, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6205169049803546, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5754868234041013, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4912056443642293, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4706603833841731, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4644278592229337, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.41758229866993324, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4098215868087086, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.522853575338011, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.46523100714800786, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3964670573341703, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3817925845681869, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.37797962006213587, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.37419693352032934, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.32775322333084717, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5961634022566685, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5122467341950143, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4319390687088067, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4317388862424566, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4210284677260965, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4097243699946093, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3748411349211112, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6440073455429213, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5658173187676727, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4790506560955632, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46409297645709835, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45274096867911656, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4445152207689025, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.44110679167642697, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 62.76% of these modeled runs. Starting with a synthetic majority tests minority protection. The model’s protection coefficients do not simulate every House, Senate or presidential election.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 62.76% of these modeled runs. Starting with a synthetic majority tests minority protection. The model’s protection coefficients do not simulate every House, Senate or presidential election."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-04", "source_scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "name": {"plain": "Almost equal populations", "technical": "Stable near parity"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.48, "syn_g": 0.006, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.24, "tech": 0.48, "prod": 0.28, "returns": 0.22, "hom": 0.3, "attacks": 0.14, "rogue": 0.08, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.12, "capacity": 0.86, "private": 0.3, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.58, "polar": 0.24}, "focus_parameters": ["s0", "hom"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.845625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.70125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.70025, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.158, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0015, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00075, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.108875, "avg_liberty": 0.7861334884631449, "avg_individuality": 0.8268195088170741, "avg_integration": 0.6818950557378878, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7098282603938902, "avg_resilience": 0.6817263923503463, "avg_prosperity": 0.30064020594426427, "avg_anti_domination": 0.9017482562074508, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8623044834076786, "avg_trust": 0.6553898970308235, "avg_inequality": 0.7085458742113669, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8313631387800617, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00863732592875504, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6760554582181056, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.675874745791354, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6750422915548953, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5689693831045824, "score_Stability-first": 0.6518890527460287, "score_Individuality-first": 0.7007408400087308}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.856875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.703125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.498875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.165875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0025, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.003, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11, "avg_liberty": 0.7482594781103967, "avg_individuality": 0.7443785182797719, "avg_integration": 0.49641757395468405, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7135304381478372, "avg_resilience": 0.4539364367235426, "avg_prosperity": 0.3058032810996401, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8571593422413185, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9186769128445924, "avg_trust": 0.6208499790932243, "avg_inequality": 0.6928353998187776, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8296933972874823, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.0065184547232520025, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5994247781095406, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6231250616102149, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6313145740139274, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5106023152241846, "score_Stability-first": 0.5662931409357562, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6266631174841347}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.818625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.610125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.24625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.22925, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.002875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10825, "avg_liberty": 0.6171291145175992, "avg_individuality": 0.660879598808037, "avg_integration": 0.4428485937120237, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6708078184202939, "avg_resilience": 0.3856739689978176, "avg_prosperity": 0.30339918850688613, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7694966247890258, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9094483051961361, "avg_trust": 0.5731243432422158, "avg_inequality": 0.6579992749738292, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.826956927652828, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008011905002347297, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5075016146742649, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5251103000999406, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5478030607957498, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4414649417132476, "score_Stability-first": 0.4867175037182679, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5286476769628863}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.679625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.539, "free_integrated_rate": 0.258375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.17325, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00025, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.002375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0035, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.098125, "avg_liberty": 0.6493719907715253, "avg_individuality": 0.6821037659798868, "avg_integration": 0.4104653333037919, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5402018009438933, "avg_resilience": 0.45520645835334617, "avg_prosperity": 0.2413021857995201, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8273874223526846, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5776577075130456, "avg_trust": 0.5078225028616579, "avg_inequality": 0.6338910271500934, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8502865394235036, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.005201748012578775, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4806932599405156, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4994688902635168, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4777904935652123, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38598662257826943, "score_Stability-first": 0.44084918691134656, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5130358271659002}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.756125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.59125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.063, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.187875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00075, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0025, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00575, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.103625, "avg_liberty": 0.6658196706463343, "avg_individuality": 0.7056607000547167, "avg_integration": 0.35590669188136476, "avg_legitimacy": 0.598504203564901, "avg_resilience": 0.515097388127395, "avg_prosperity": 0.2674763404743504, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8557104759294084, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7286856760204541, "avg_trust": 0.5298260215142419, "avg_inequality": 0.6592936975118849, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8421429152018427, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.005539758449752041, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5199062533811181, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5431784146919825, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5302039238476486, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4385661442344929, "score_Stability-first": 0.49656287794079845, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5482083004400782}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.720375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.388, "free_integrated_rate": 0.131375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.41125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.102375, "avg_liberty": 0.5382459014626961, "avg_individuality": 0.7331471695278533, "avg_integration": 0.4949968177230301, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4929544140293943, "avg_resilience": 0.5957730358525862, "avg_prosperity": 0.2929421024796756, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7891083279497552, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8664842450942942, "avg_trust": 0.4672977127930067, "avg_inequality": 0.6350673484005566, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8225254266332203, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.007102327096767211, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4730506484349071, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4678256800543483, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4622129957517237, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4120462499931218, "score_Stability-first": 0.46822436327505, "score_Individuality-first": 0.496279638276345}, {"scenario": "04 Stable near parity", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.80775, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5665, "free_integrated_rate": 0.187375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.27, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.002875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.108, "avg_liberty": 0.6265649872145849, "avg_individuality": 0.6764342073614473, "avg_integration": 0.4192280665139843, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6358657275924643, "avg_resilience": 0.36335385499424083, "avg_prosperity": 0.2977759454161329, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7660454366026411, "avg_governance_eff": 0.90529375, "avg_trust": 0.5443255637317959, "avg_inequality": 0.6273132235640949, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8296168160861553, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.007805130013292908, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.49071747320465425, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.512608445730683, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5261838617887593, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4224453216495471, "score_Stability-first": 0.4631957214905707, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5163081242704709}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6760554582181056, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5994247781095406, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5199062533811181, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5075016146742649, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.49071747320465425, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4806932599405156, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4730506484349071, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.675874745791354, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6231250616102149, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5431784146919825, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5251103000999406, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.512608445730683, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4994688902635168, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4678256800543483, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6750422915548953, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6313145740139274, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5478030607957498, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5302039238476486, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5261838617887593, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4777904935652123, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4622129957517237, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5689693831045824, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5106023152241846, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4414649417132476, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4385661442344929, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4224453216495471, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4120462499931218, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38598662257826943, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6518890527460287, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5662931409357562, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.49656287794079845, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4867175037182679, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.46822436327505, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4631957214905707, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.44084918691134656, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7007408400087308, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6266631174841347, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5482083004400782, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5286476769628863, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5163081242704709, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5130358271659002, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.496279638276345, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 70.03% of these modeled runs. Near parity is a starting condition, not a promise of permanent equal population sizes. Demographic growth continues during the run.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 70.03% of these modeled runs. Near parity is a starting condition, not a promise of permanent equal population sizes. Demographic growth continues during the run."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-05", "source_scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "name": {"plain": "The human/organic population contracts", "technical": "Organic demographic contraction"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.28, "syn_g": 0.012, "org_g": -0.006, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.52, "prod": 0.35, "returns": 0.32, "hom": 0.35, "attacks": 0.18, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.12, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.36, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.5, "polar": 0.32}, "focus_parameters": ["org_g", "syn_g"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.82375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.669125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.658, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.169375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.002875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.122, "avg_liberty": 0.7540524531580928, "avg_individuality": 0.7987258559528543, "avg_integration": 0.6330332524594119, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6786136234295832, "avg_resilience": 0.6453191019207634, "avg_prosperity": 0.29058858447533803, "avg_anti_domination": 0.875606728617857, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8354819080614068, "avg_trust": 0.6145481492505339, "avg_inequality": 0.6321013391306742, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9887183188695678, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011245396805535266, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.636180166228515, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6380113689649315, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.635362050632554, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5332536401149384, "score_Stability-first": 0.611489023229815, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6605531550879985}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.839625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.665375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.34275, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.178875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.017875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.123125, "avg_liberty": 0.7238105919039249, "avg_individuality": 0.7183055546366831, "avg_integration": 0.45638995971504087, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6874299782773804, "avg_resilience": 0.4337471496211022, "avg_prosperity": 0.2964042068058573, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8152589690116049, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9006220629840327, "avg_trust": 0.5859322922791662, "avg_inequality": 0.6199738473082976, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.988917982759652, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008571554222722766, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5619359949556184, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5870557138203591, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5942143463200613, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.47834625025150823, "score_Stability-first": 0.5305251254528313, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5881176711956512}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.798625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5785, "free_integrated_rate": 0.112, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.240625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.019, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.015375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12075, "avg_liberty": 0.5969602165098788, "avg_individuality": 0.6334474952499755, "avg_integration": 0.40226360782133924, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6478722332405717, "avg_resilience": 0.36867496054612, "avg_prosperity": 0.2937978586196939, "avg_anti_domination": 0.700902454956963, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8984063470042554, "avg_trust": 0.5403225407707368, "avg_inequality": 0.5863949467293823, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9887522129276365, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010456732016532787, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.46889152779011667, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4885197890960842, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5111534233177868, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.41021576129247117, "score_Stability-first": 0.4513575954351582, "score_Individuality-first": 0.48877020478351796}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.63775, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.49175, "free_integrated_rate": 0.14575, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1845, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00325, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1105, "avg_liberty": 0.6114501372098946, "avg_individuality": 0.6413229605058687, "avg_integration": 0.3645820340600646, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5034434285376752, "avg_resilience": 0.4229470543207179, "avg_prosperity": 0.22704149596309964, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7883532565167523, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5411065039544868, "avg_trust": 0.46346056045856165, "avg_inequality": 0.5537877605086187, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9904917521727158, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.006911281768384777, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4316235300652645, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45116752329619597, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.42846841213300796, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3422513280947197, "score_Stability-first": 0.39307539072131664, "score_Individuality-first": 0.46222329573628046}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.712625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.545, "free_integrated_rate": 0.019375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.198, "bifurcation_rate": 0.008125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00925, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11525, "avg_liberty": 0.6310896755737884, "avg_individuality": 0.6669321202639827, "avg_integration": 0.3147613677594299, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5621284910356308, "avg_resilience": 0.4811638371334469, "avg_prosperity": 0.2530804297242226, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8164641097562975, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6897915006547535, "avg_trust": 0.48702414264257904, "avg_inequality": 0.5790381334708287, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9899078797611202, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.007338670097648042, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4718633373940313, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4959137196572132, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4815742788895474, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3948889509238511, "score_Stability-first": 0.4488167554941479, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4987658745999065}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.693375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.366125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.067875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.417, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.009125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.010625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.114625, "avg_liberty": 0.5142639202131403, "avg_individuality": 0.7024870523504109, "avg_integration": 0.45056304663352453, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4728225212974428, "avg_resilience": 0.5615747846835366, "avg_prosperity": 0.28195942289833337, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7368298322098086, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8473164772766261, "avg_trust": 0.43487824799988317, "avg_inequality": 0.5609481390243336, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9882254903066826, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00931503149397391, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4347955045533942, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4321111761442461, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4269278914874569, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37914602295612576, "score_Stability-first": 0.43081268233818504, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45717163807097017}, {"scenario": "05 Organic demographic contraction", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.787, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.532, "free_integrated_rate": 0.085125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.285375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0185, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.120125, "avg_liberty": 0.6057903338484675, "avg_individuality": 0.6483817240994495, "avg_integration": 0.3797583467555221, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6141197979554331, "avg_resilience": 0.3477608573483589, "avg_prosperity": 0.2878064090810464, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7014823433309889, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8937625, "avg_trust": 0.5125817724549749, "avg_inequality": 0.556909630411525, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9889926870251378, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01019479897731543, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4523004139748464, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4759175212824444, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4897065132265123, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.39108399957445267, "score_Stability-first": 0.428218722414852, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4764117860279919}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.636180166228515, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5619359949556184, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4718633373940313, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46889152779011667, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4523004139748464, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4347955045533942, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4316235300652645, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6380113689649315, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5870557138203591, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4959137196572132, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4885197890960842, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4759175212824444, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.45116752329619597, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4321111761442461, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.635362050632554, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5942143463200613, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5111534233177868, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4897065132265123, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4815742788895474, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.42846841213300796, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4269278914874569, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5332536401149384, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.47834625025150823, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.41021576129247117, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3948889509238511, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.39108399957445267, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.37914602295612576, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3422513280947197, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.611489023229815, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5305251254528313, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4513575954351582, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4488167554941479, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.43081268233818504, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.428218722414852, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.39307539072131664, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6605531550879985, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5881176711956512, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4987658745999065, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.48877020478351796, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4764117860279919, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.46222329573628046, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.45717163807097017, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 65.80% of these modeled runs. The organic population’s negative baseline growth puts preservation and political standing under pressure. This is an assumed trajectory, not demographic evidence.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 65.80% of these modeled runs. The organic population’s negative baseline growth puts preservation and political standing under pressure. This is an assumed trajectory, not demographic evidence."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-06", "source_scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "name": {"plain": "Abundant cheap computing and energy", "technical": "Cheap compute energy boom"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.2, "syn_g": 0.035, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.08, "tech": 0.9, "prod": 0.7, "returns": 0.35, "hom": 0.28, "attacks": 0.22, "rogue": 0.18, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.1, "capacity": 0.86, "private": 0.42, "planets": 0.12, "abundance": 0.9, "polar": 0.25}, "focus_parameters": ["tech", "scarcity", "abundance"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.848, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.686375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.6845, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.16625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.015, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.001, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10875, "avg_liberty": 0.7840840544896724, "avg_individuality": 0.801179998354862, "avg_integration": 0.6904023995916063, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7074708307951703, "avg_resilience": 0.676347613171899, "avg_prosperity": 0.3871133980760678, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8892962896082183, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8606540297673393, "avg_trust": 0.6460321878705639, "avg_inequality": 0.6049208582657171, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9994413384249758, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.03059171616765505, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6689222072895369, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6695389823952614, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6674709458686093, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.58036940336373, "score_Stability-first": 0.6463425228844325, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6868569790739352}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.856, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.669, "free_integrated_rate": 0.474375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1775, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.03375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.004375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.109, "avg_liberty": 0.7448756947533915, "avg_individuality": 0.6969841763438371, "avg_integration": 0.5024439425426093, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7079430218731209, "avg_resilience": 0.4482818106403096, "avg_prosperity": 0.38873771935193274, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8088134732676839, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9146139018479948, "avg_trust": 0.609591369980854, "avg_inequality": 0.5871924770194427, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9995855158612171, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.023106725503473553, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5776694001719286, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6022915309156566, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6112467642664065, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5112967721340416, "score_Stability-first": 0.5492330932304949, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5959501341249082}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.812, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.578375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.06425, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.23975, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0355, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0095, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.107375, "avg_liberty": 0.6126099094506681, "avg_individuality": 0.6079295047313056, "avg_integration": 0.44538647521604513, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6633626478217312, "avg_resilience": 0.37959710696950894, "avg_prosperity": 0.3810533707991737, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6739799850896384, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9046038440769805, "avg_trust": 0.5609604467217009, "avg_inequality": 0.5538075963021825, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9996008889805942, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.028470389908038247, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.47704118038258897, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.49606320012043986, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5207768067918018, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4364957069853696, "score_Stability-first": 0.4629449867282475, "score_Individuality-first": 0.48929385337854475}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.67625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.519, "free_integrated_rate": 0.275625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.182125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.02525, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.004625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.098625, "avg_liberty": 0.6432035480090773, "avg_individuality": 0.6376261666840194, "avg_integration": 0.4156389830732371, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5352119376251289, "avg_resilience": 0.4470251080258249, "avg_prosperity": 0.3062049066176064, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8118049248972451, "avg_governance_eff": 0.572263388726228, "avg_trust": 0.49602505972442973, "avg_inequality": 0.5374869588978061, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9996478978266354, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.018398516501797857, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4655415607127803, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4843941657240258, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.46364637198005065, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38717072006915143, "score_Stability-first": 0.4289132489710449, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4897302606344809}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.75025, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.568125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.075, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.196875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.027375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.103875, "avg_liberty": 0.6598832953825905, "avg_individuality": 0.6579714796003653, "avg_integration": 0.36181076356900327, "avg_legitimacy": 0.59279216500755, "avg_resilience": 0.5068720999964959, "avg_prosperity": 0.3382011438523965, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8333033415122236, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7228665676348058, "avg_trust": 0.5176637121610465, "avg_inequality": 0.5579571682165665, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9996229322589782, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01960506970154059, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5027483856651015, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5262246246931599, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5142025723353788, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.43956568647327443, "score_Stability-first": 0.48304553955635654, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5223397354659292}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.714875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.382375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.126, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4085, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01825, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.101625, "avg_liberty": 0.5325178175009261, "avg_individuality": 0.6948790466922816, "avg_integration": 0.49833445721761144, "avg_legitimacy": 0.48737555400431304, "avg_resilience": 0.5889512992297178, "avg_prosperity": 0.3695931031409874, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7343445192404108, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8588452610425489, "avg_trust": 0.45597971698344086, "avg_inequality": 0.5348323179182114, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9994429550475851, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.025201642067024757, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.45682363420427474, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4525845923964017, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4473933690091453, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.41680050383629863, "score_Stability-first": 0.45593993057893323, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4727475445648449}, {"scenario": "06 Cheap compute energy boom", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.802375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.533875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.110375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.283875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.03525, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00975, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.106875, "avg_liberty": 0.622044345122869, "avg_individuality": 0.6241159340296191, "avg_integration": 0.42254272545622984, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6288636132385637, "avg_resilience": 0.3576173625976667, "avg_prosperity": 0.3734182553124375, "avg_anti_domination": 0.677170882972531, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9010056343950654, "avg_trust": 0.5326067134547944, "avg_inequality": 0.5242302999013791, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.999617709948776, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.027726386586154218, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.461274523145641, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4843779217226224, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5000067382150148, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4175487134004804, "score_Stability-first": 0.4402359128738511, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4780064079411174}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6689222072895369, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5776694001719286, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5027483856651015, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.47704118038258897, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4655415607127803, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.461274523145641, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.45682363420427474, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6695389823952614, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6022915309156566, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5262246246931599, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.49606320012043986, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4843941657240258, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4843779217226224, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4525845923964017, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6674709458686093, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6112467642664065, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5207768067918018, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5142025723353788, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5000067382150148, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.46364637198005065, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4473933690091453, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.58036940336373, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5112967721340416, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43956568647327443, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4364957069853696, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4175487134004804, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.41680050383629863, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38717072006915143, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6463425228844325, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5492330932304949, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.48304553955635654, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4629449867282475, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.45593993057893323, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4402359128738511, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4289132489710449, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6868569790739352, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5959501341249082, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5223397354659292, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4897302606344809, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.48929385337854475, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4780064079411174, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4727475445648449, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 68.45% of these modeled runs. Cheap resources ease some pressures but do not remove power, rights or coordination problems. The model does not estimate real electricity prices.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 68.45% of these modeled runs. Cheap resources ease some pressures but do not remove power, rights or coordination problems. The model does not estimate real electricity prices."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-07", "source_scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "name": {"plain": "Scarce computing and energy", "technical": "Compute and energy scarcity"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.22, "syn_g": 0.008, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.78, "tech": 0.45, "prod": 0.3, "returns": 0.28, "hom": 0.42, "attacks": 0.25, "rogue": 0.12, "disaster": 0.18, "ext": 0.2, "capacity": 0.72, "private": 0.5, "planets": 0.05, "abundance": 0.2, "polar": 0.52}, "focus_parameters": ["scarcity", "capacity"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7525, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.5835, "free_integrated_rate": 0.511, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.19975, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.01075, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.160625, "avg_liberty": 0.6741854140844122, "avg_individuality": 0.7239508829698641, "avg_integration": 0.5285323115680604, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5878233061829558, "avg_resilience": 0.5460458206613226, "avg_prosperity": 0.21668336058801765, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8342894754268352, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7606826416584468, "avg_trust": 0.5230294173066474, "avg_inequality": 0.5786547272218474, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.6625133144993061, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012899612087714746, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5387847820419664, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.544028346509283, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5374362470351812, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4358170226975475, "score_Stability-first": 0.5107201840258462, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5650924075591839}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.790375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.607875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.133875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.209125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.007125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.025375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.163625, "avg_liberty": 0.6630172054091424, "avg_individuality": 0.6629428068512156, "avg_integration": 0.3818505590429541, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6130882826235532, "avg_resilience": 0.38089776122110724, "avg_prosperity": 0.22530654437005235, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8064150492986089, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8486786228175396, "avg_trust": 0.511089318343959, "avg_inequality": 0.5778273395804071, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.6598568467281919, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010022517222523262, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4947966871173465, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5203089954564232, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5237658413326903, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4074991293707326, "score_Stability-first": 0.46278976514444414, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5216271236402803}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.754125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.515625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.015375, "domination_rate": 0.015, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2715, "bifurcation_rate": 0.017125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000125, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.113125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.161625, "avg_liberty": 0.5500213268523656, "avg_individuality": 0.5879471565153215, "avg_integration": 0.3360064921548239, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5876150306945885, "avg_resilience": 0.3280243169668667, "avg_prosperity": 0.22555312554965462, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7203560675401538, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8745697726911726, "avg_trust": 0.47657078375291473, "avg_inequality": 0.5489511496200694, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.656309542465568, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012054452879225923, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4138315604475925, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4338584145739881, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4537187197255479, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3493158772227927, "score_Stability-first": 0.39615122849387974, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43380877688884567}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.521625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.389, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0315, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.20725, "bifurcation_rate": 0.13625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0015, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.037375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1405, "avg_liberty": 0.533165812951736, "avg_individuality": 0.5642182825231803, "avg_integration": 0.28604394322182464, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4175948926046594, "avg_resilience": 0.35459053179840727, "avg_prosperity": 0.1647114801327346, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7249066444898388, "avg_governance_eff": 0.46588641981877216, "avg_trust": 0.37839708840588065, "avg_inequality": 0.4907782815612412, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.6818020833881512, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008232621018176914, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.32470031233223995, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.34433334299291535, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.31931071068644934, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.23873349612053407, "score_Stability-first": 0.28708426349859806, "score_Individuality-first": 0.35458570941168943}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.619875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.453125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.002375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2265, "bifurcation_rate": 0.256375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.079125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.149625, "avg_liberty": 0.5609392525676093, "avg_individuality": 0.5982433673130798, "avg_integration": 0.24763343768003118, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4777110738504276, "avg_resilience": 0.409251761252188, "avg_prosperity": 0.18629330896570268, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7691765724267577, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6132347209213476, "avg_trust": 0.407240935846019, "avg_inequality": 0.5239684089081142, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.674322676724083, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008697410907122897, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.36438920665244373, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.3883896689295239, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3707306705228925, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.28649881016118245, "score_Stability-first": 0.33934015462263617, "score_Individuality-first": 0.3917904819329731}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.627, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.31575, "free_integrated_rate": 0.007875, "domination_rate": 0.000125, "authoritarian_rate": 0.428875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.008625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.09725, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.15075, "avg_liberty": 0.46615873552797576, "avg_individuality": 0.6423542340422755, "avg_integration": 0.3741029864908021, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4219163624881566, "avg_resilience": 0.48460097580416983, "avg_prosperity": 0.21475424278833588, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7231030857506165, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8117724270268744, "avg_trust": 0.37527570740884414, "avg_inequality": 0.5172115220761059, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.6525986698373907, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010844184964994478, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3697274971531019, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.37016013740003767, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.36503297563517584, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.31008388023941963, "score_Stability-first": 0.3632624027053924, "score_Individuality-first": 0.3925413011523639}, {"scenario": "07 Compute and energy scarcity", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.74625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.47525, "free_integrated_rate": 0.012625, "domination_rate": 0.0085, "authoritarian_rate": 0.315375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.01625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.001875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.128875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.161125, "avg_liberty": 0.5600832917376818, "avg_individuality": 0.6029222632599712, "avg_integration": 0.31640962705530984, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5583656551987115, "avg_resilience": 0.31117618616420323, "avg_prosperity": 0.2212164504509735, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7184386810979115, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8719670147537366, "avg_trust": 0.452906023572979, "avg_inequality": 0.5233847054933509, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.6590790253064317, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011769951209535343, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.40019528251941305, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.42395488502172374, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4357786802576603, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.33361640592815966, "score_Stability-first": 0.37675872922567166, "score_Individuality-first": 0.42404072482638877}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5387847820419664, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4947966871173465, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4138315604475925, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.40019528251941305, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3697274971531019, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.36438920665244373, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.32470031233223995, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.544028346509283, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5203089954564232, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4338584145739881, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.42395488502172374, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3883896689295239, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.37016013740003767, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.34433334299291535, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5374362470351812, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5237658413326903, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4537187197255479, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4357786802576603, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3707306705228925, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.36503297563517584, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.31931071068644934, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4358170226975475, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4074991293707326, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3493158772227927, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.33361640592815966, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.31008388023941963, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.28649881016118245, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.23873349612053407, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5107201840258462, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.46278976514444414, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.39615122849387974, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.37675872922567166, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3632624027053924, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.33934015462263617, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.28708426349859806, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5650924075591839, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5216271236402803, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.43380877688884567, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.42404072482638877, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3925413011523639, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3917904819329731, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.35458570941168943, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 51.10% of these modeled runs. Resource limits increase strain. A relative lead does not mean freedom and cooperation survive in every run.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 51.10% of these modeled runs. Resource limits increase strain. A relative lead does not mean freedom and cooperation survive in every run."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-08", "source_scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "name": {"plain": "A leap in synthetic productivity", "technical": "Synthetic productivity leap"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.18, "syn_g": 0.025, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.28, "tech": 0.82, "prod": 0.9, "returns": 0.52, "hom": 0.38, "attacks": 0.24, "rogue": 0.15, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.14, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.48, "planets": 0.1, "abundance": 0.65, "polar": 0.42}, "focus_parameters": ["prod", "returns"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.82525, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6575, "free_integrated_rate": 0.63525, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.179125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0105, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.003625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.109125, "avg_liberty": 0.7568951237470374, "avg_individuality": 0.7650435080697735, "avg_integration": 0.6092868034906174, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6730434184098686, "avg_resilience": 0.6319471248050292, "avg_prosperity": 0.34729350248924074, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8735911590795672, "avg_governance_eff": 0.830721283210165, "avg_trust": 0.5880291963845816, "avg_inequality": 0.4939794795021919, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9977471344190715, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.023636899558075925, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6218261269984685, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6270442534519911, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6218352483807041, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5319414381912314, "score_Stability-first": 0.5978454282956134, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6399272838518412}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.840375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.648875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.217375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1925, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.023375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11025, "avg_liberty": 0.7251123639840287, "avg_individuality": 0.6687373646967897, "avg_integration": 0.4289872574474547, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6805610113119003, "avg_resilience": 0.4239738604154265, "avg_prosperity": 0.3505080060998596, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7954954170235887, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8969384465608629, "avg_trust": 0.5578310070396242, "avg_inequality": 0.4791494383320319, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9979244868886625, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.017892142802253083, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5405531161981124, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5689687740179652, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5751118285094334, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.472713555740615, "score_Stability-first": 0.5126955019146592, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5585056699087256}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.800875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.555375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.008375, "domination_rate": 0.006875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.256875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0245, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.043875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.108375, "avg_liberty": 0.5981495093943734, "avg_individuality": 0.584144036769905, "avg_integration": 0.37530488005570695, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6439495693800324, "avg_resilience": 0.3612373329486072, "avg_prosperity": 0.34527341339864015, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6610999035820451, "avg_governance_eff": 0.901911381347775, "avg_trust": 0.5146925376912791, "avg_inequality": 0.4501649956931846, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9979257628797383, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.021980661804131427, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4440212268324678, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4669217353272618, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4899079391286323, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4023791283719239, "score_Stability-first": 0.43145626292352024, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4556961416456633}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.6425, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.48375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.08525, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.198, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0195, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0175, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.008, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.097875, "avg_liberty": 0.6178522796490399, "avg_individuality": 0.6042148214946724, "avg_integration": 0.34372214665706474, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5007255640397587, "avg_resilience": 0.41670032306520427, "avg_prosperity": 0.2707418246307982, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7914695155193072, "avg_governance_eff": 0.536130492062194, "avg_trust": 0.4421817142961606, "avg_inequality": 0.43559752410482633, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.998337769745479, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01430888805883194, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4189044087221273, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44128201602788997, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4169061867284023, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3399995063495694, "score_Stability-first": 0.3820420530965313, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4429178649539799}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.72225, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.535875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.009875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2135, "bifurcation_rate": 0.05075, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0195, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.012875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.102875, "avg_liberty": 0.6365221214517428, "avg_individuality": 0.6257790051419911, "avg_integration": 0.29108468228396955, "avg_legitimacy": 0.558433269065699, "avg_resilience": 0.47297407025465, "avg_prosperity": 0.300495635507371, "avg_anti_domination": 0.814878783561131, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6851629654816422, "avg_trust": 0.4637762025027659, "avg_inequality": 0.45292752924766666, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9981936704835043, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01522952256234224, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4545409162996523, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.48172740928953284, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4658151045102793, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38956330248243887, "score_Stability-first": 0.43357011660154265, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4743341340592847}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.704375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.363625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.05275, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4215, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0145, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0205, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.102625, "avg_liberty": 0.519631447382337, "avg_individuality": 0.669656168803807, "avg_integration": 0.42972681269474267, "avg_legitimacy": 0.47306845182125346, "avg_resilience": 0.5560018979600887, "avg_prosperity": 0.3364491904018992, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7241458320306201, "avg_governance_eff": 0.856710672962231, "avg_trust": 0.41428789449598225, "avg_inequality": 0.4370509007302155, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9976619055696734, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01950312420162802, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42440835079314887, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4248685111068059, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4188528514443003, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3828329321437488, "score_Stability-first": 0.4232388734713046, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4401175229655845}, {"scenario": "08 Synthetic productivity leap", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.79025, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.510625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.014125, "domination_rate": 0.0065, "authoritarian_rate": 0.300125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0245, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.05525, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.107625, "avg_liberty": 0.60736655899773, "avg_individuality": 0.5994593020809666, "avg_integration": 0.35300104576702473, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6100125663846678, "avg_resilience": 0.3405819702102938, "avg_prosperity": 0.3358099952168039, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6639610689177643, "avg_governance_eff": 0.897637496436186, "avg_trust": 0.487020505960796, "avg_inequality": 0.4215279651687822, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9980223432858801, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.021411478993937708, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42813387227207056, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45491935791248994, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.469075602566169, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3830407825666957, "score_Stability-first": 0.40889351582606526, "score_Individuality-first": 0.44416657495206846}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6218261269984685, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5405531161981124, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4545409162996523, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4440212268324678, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.42813387227207056, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.42440835079314887, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4189044087221273, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6270442534519911, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5689687740179652, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.48172740928953284, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4669217353272618, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45491935791248994, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.44128201602788997, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4248685111068059, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6218352483807041, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5751118285094334, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4899079391286323, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.469075602566169, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4658151045102793, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4188528514443003, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4169061867284023, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5319414381912314, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.472713555740615, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4023791283719239, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.38956330248243887, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3830407825666957, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3828329321437488, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3399995063495694, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5978454282956134, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5126955019146592, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43357011660154265, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.43145626292352024, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4232388734713046, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.40889351582606526, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3820420530965313, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6399272838518412, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5585056699087256, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4743341340592847, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4556961416456633, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.44416657495206846, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4429178649539799, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4401175229655845, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 63.52% of these modeled runs. Higher productivity also changes power and wealth pressures. The model cannot settle whether future synthetic capabilities would have these effects.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 63.52% of these modeled runs. Higher productivity also changes power and wealth pressures. The model cannot settle whether future synthetic capabilities would have these effects."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-09", "source_scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "name": {"plain": "Wealth advantages last for generations", "technical": "Durable-capital concentration"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.25, "syn_g": 0.014, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.62, "prod": 0.52, "returns": 0.9, "hom": 0.36, "attacks": 0.18, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.12, "capacity": 0.8, "private": 0.68, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.52, "polar": 0.45}, "focus_parameters": ["returns", "private"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.799, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.633125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.611875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.186625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.005875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.005, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12525, "avg_liberty": 0.7340371936490316, "avg_individuality": 0.7651870552918368, "avg_integration": 0.6008989399035684, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6491785271316283, "avg_resilience": 0.609006194434887, "avg_prosperity": 0.29521247049881594, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8586752360643116, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8103363030368758, "avg_trust": 0.5579604342379919, "avg_inequality": 0.38392139576572504, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.965069818991032, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012486653367974557, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5956080109519607, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5980019898628056, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5922988615608576, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4943531958822166, "score_Stability-first": 0.5673455097793104, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6162480215063172}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.821, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.254875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.198625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01175, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.009125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.126625, "avg_liberty": 0.7076020531554889, "avg_individuality": 0.679151074731416, "avg_integration": 0.4306649833457051, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6612299650137117, "avg_resilience": 0.4118812481842737, "avg_prosperity": 0.3009571939783871, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7974284258378684, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8817930447817959, "avg_trust": 0.5324080037165095, "avg_inequality": 0.37054795717219635, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9650414613300022, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009548407688497296, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5259703877272293, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5506800445068499, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5558030298284123, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4448068942144648, "score_Stability-first": 0.4934630004952369, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5466824855828498}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.780125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.54675, "free_integrated_rate": 0.035125, "domination_rate": 0.006875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.258875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.037, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12425, "avg_liberty": 0.5844330913929754, "avg_individuality": 0.5958934857043982, "avg_integration": 0.3787979718715498, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6266271282950128, "avg_resilience": 0.3511471528902348, "avg_prosperity": 0.298174103757221, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6798534462503596, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8885623406963159, "avg_trust": 0.4909393408070877, "avg_inequality": 0.34393710597741095, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9643650509829066, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01162128528177481, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4344501895093812, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4537242556086175, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4751875865590526, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37848582486898524, "score_Stability-first": 0.41669864952786717, "score_Individuality-first": 0.44866230271278795}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.597375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.452, "free_integrated_rate": 0.093375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.19675, "bifurcation_rate": 0.029125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0085, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00925, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11125, "avg_liberty": 0.5927671024862083, "avg_individuality": 0.6023941836425399, "avg_integration": 0.3392464634741927, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4763173906148851, "avg_resilience": 0.39859082241607724, "avg_prosperity": 0.22757758430540775, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7686127189114561, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5155510073514266, "avg_trust": 0.4127745355390025, "avg_inequality": 0.3319419854983834, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.970478334408977, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.0077191122818268424, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.39026057715886103, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4093600522749296, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.38475345287551704, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.30284896287403434, "score_Stability-first": 0.3503997816483824, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4161181902935876}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.682125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.511, "free_integrated_rate": 0.009625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.213375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.07675, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00925, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.015375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.117625, "avg_liberty": 0.6147688154722806, "avg_individuality": 0.6286160179374352, "avg_integration": 0.291819003410365, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5353521654674205, "avg_resilience": 0.4545497836481312, "avg_prosperity": 0.2549921096929033, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7991899555935136, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6640566737070733, "avg_trust": 0.4362006478771144, "avg_inequality": 0.34707660109378424, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9685666709429311, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008191067204718657, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42902243937255696, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4527085930315617, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4361825104820201, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35340218650597977, "score_Stability-first": 0.4038197689835152, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4511757518133553}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.67225, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.345875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.044, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.42675, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00025, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.007125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.021375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.117, "avg_liberty": 0.5047948229453804, "avg_individuality": 0.6734840910187875, "avg_integration": 0.42753585890240137, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4585018232913011, "avg_resilience": 0.5369944084036109, "avg_prosperity": 0.2889726918318945, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7238517860769782, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8399546607088857, "avg_trust": 0.39177092070089076, "avg_inequality": 0.3340305960656104, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9626315473875521, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010369721441418166, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4067512722761889, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.40453885563680614, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3983064306292684, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35266220729266073, "score_Stability-first": 0.4008191064004063, "score_Individuality-first": 0.42474788337887814}, {"scenario": "09 Durable-capital concentration", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.767875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.49925, "free_integrated_rate": 0.039, "domination_rate": 0.007125, "authoritarian_rate": 0.303125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.045625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1235, "avg_liberty": 0.5927279725520418, "avg_individuality": 0.6088058998138844, "avg_integration": 0.35661549970822004, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5927934321638415, "avg_resilience": 0.3302940088683922, "avg_prosperity": 0.2904464784396126, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6795177688399283, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8834718717560015, "avg_trust": 0.46349911021898405, "avg_inequality": 0.316182880129589, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9653817775870774, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011333123900912451, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.41702428610821146, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44014738103381074, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.45306659944666267, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3584333773891635, "score_Stability-first": 0.3929758023474232, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4352843298338159}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5956080109519607, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5259703877272293, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4344501895093812, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.42902243937255696, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.41702428610821146, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4067512722761889, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.39026057715886103, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5980019898628056, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5506800445068499, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4537242556086175, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4527085930315617, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.44014738103381074, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4093600522749296, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.40453885563680614, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5922988615608576, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5558030298284123, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4751875865590526, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45306659944666267, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4361825104820201, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3983064306292684, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38475345287551704, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4943531958822166, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4448068942144648, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.37848582486898524, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3584333773891635, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.35340218650597977, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.35266220729266073, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.30284896287403434, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5673455097793104, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4934630004952369, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.41669864952786717, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4038197689835152, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4008191064004063, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3929758023474232, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3503997816483824, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6162480215063172, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5466824855828498, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4511757518133553, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44866230271278795, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4352843298338159, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.42474788337887814, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4161181902935876, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 61.19% of these modeled runs. Persistent returns and private concentration test whether formal rights remain useful under economic dependence. The model does not settle the required economic architecture.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 61.19% of these modeled runs. Persistent returns and private concentration test whether formal rights remain useful under economic dependence. The model does not settle the required economic architecture."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-10", "source_scenario": "10 High functional integration", "name": {"plain": "Frequent cooperation across populations", "technical": "High functional integration"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.3, "syn_g": 0.012, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.24, "tech": 0.55, "prod": 0.4, "returns": 0.28, "hom": 0.08, "attacks": 0.14, "rogue": 0.08, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.1, "capacity": 0.88, "private": 0.3, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.6, "polar": 0.12}, "focus_parameters": ["hom", "polar"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.858375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.707875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.70775, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1615, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00225, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00025, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.104625, "avg_liberty": 0.801427134827031, "avg_individuality": 0.8480514997022133, "avg_integration": 0.8073563530534362, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7304948042312126, "avg_resilience": 0.7160630508619047, "avg_prosperity": 0.31740327708546623, "avg_anti_domination": 0.9067343463906691, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8794083499786868, "avg_trust": 0.6942633969715678, "avg_inequality": 0.6871194875868685, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9320040751548565, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00918750700559058, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.708194696577199, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6967502878421004, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.7014102573317292, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5940396170597986, "score_Stability-first": 0.6821917183639757, "score_Individuality-first": 0.7302267592251964}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.864125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.7, "free_integrated_rate": 0.69575, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.172375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.001, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10475, "avg_liberty": 0.7584977371404245, "avg_individuality": 0.7584560333002869, "avg_integration": 0.6171920116857335, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7287042612301794, "avg_resilience": 0.4747483654744367, "avg_prosperity": 0.32007112504160873, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8500424521653598, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9257751569266592, "avg_trust": 0.6550083905684765, "avg_inequality": 0.667868634135202, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9317638256585199, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00691301744785864, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6218452259524598, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6348101497107336, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6484950901054872, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5265202861106191, "score_Stability-first": 0.585877053206817, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6466978101441614}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.820125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.60675, "free_integrated_rate": 0.506125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2345, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.007125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00425, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.102875, "avg_liberty": 0.6221873469000996, "avg_individuality": 0.669403543008515, "avg_integration": 0.560599728080535, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6795477167474299, "avg_resilience": 0.40045383444429344, "avg_prosperity": 0.31414179330287584, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7476575069020613, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9084838984147393, "avg_trust": 0.6032146473614505, "avg_inequality": 0.6309297521673366, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.931107621348997, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008514826521586163, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5233373129447924, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5302201190625501, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5583587747561741, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.45160870011971677, "score_Stability-first": 0.4996988854338005, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5422314663775382}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.713375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.565875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.551375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.179875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.005125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.001625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.096375, "avg_liberty": 0.6672224741999393, "avg_individuality": 0.7054437228703296, "avg_integration": 0.5360498349724805, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5671724214973087, "avg_resilience": 0.4832501716391653, "avg_prosperity": 0.2587165873404972, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8407393714924635, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6105385241759761, "avg_trust": 0.550153642419134, "avg_inequality": 0.6209282671699616, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9413776511951367, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.005505356587267612, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5202485000656957, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5283522658797094, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5134035106110977, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4181010581915656, "score_Stability-first": 0.47815676262446527, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5500608881317426}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.778625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.60875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.503375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.192, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.005125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00275, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.100875, "avg_liberty": 0.6795137224298835, "avg_individuality": 0.7245929993416302, "avg_integration": 0.4814576356308206, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6231320483236179, "avg_resilience": 0.5453460314610385, "avg_prosperity": 0.2843675198163696, "avg_anti_domination": 0.862070676174005, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7602783385116096, "avg_trust": 0.5697214463198668, "avg_inequality": 0.6407697604207117, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9373893224990711, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00586578343700101, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5546885878737248, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5667033405283619, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5609583522476521, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.46698210695532405, "score_Stability-first": 0.5301888577390593, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5798380122180012}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.72825, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.387875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.182625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4155, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.003125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.09875, "avg_liberty": 0.5437305453756146, "avg_individuality": 0.7465024919541832, "avg_integration": 0.6077695825386513, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5005903157748983, "avg_resilience": 0.6240208262652287, "avg_prosperity": 0.3046278252706525, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7786168503097289, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8665156294107044, "avg_trust": 0.49580897090011017, "avg_inequality": 0.6105497314848192, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9285845349192732, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.007536341567752288, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.49340741678466343, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4772825718146522, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4759164299988902, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.42680595528019055, "score_Stability-first": 0.486974304749821, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5143241749296004}, {"scenario": "10 High functional integration", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.8105, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.56175, "free_integrated_rate": 0.50525, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.278, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.007, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.004375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1025, "avg_liberty": 0.6316883507564209, "avg_individuality": 0.6854639977721246, "avg_integration": 0.5366313784582589, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6442250700329958, "avg_resilience": 0.37679465313153687, "avg_prosperity": 0.30795849370900663, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7463466716973387, "avg_governance_eff": 0.904675, "avg_trust": 0.5740975670166518, "avg_inequality": 0.6002787783462419, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9326223289107445, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.008293028079307766, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5063921108497014, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5176330129004014, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5365357639280178, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.432097292787772, "score_Stability-first": 0.47571545684561445, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5298682436662951}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.708194696577199, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6218452259524598, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5546885878737248, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5233373129447924, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5202485000656957, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5063921108497014, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.49340741678466343, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6967502878421004, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6348101497107336, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5667033405283619, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5302201190625501, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5283522658797094, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5176330129004014, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4772825718146522, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7014102573317292, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6484950901054872, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5609583522476521, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5583587747561741, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5365357639280178, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5134035106110977, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4759164299988902, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5940396170597986, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5265202861106191, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.46698210695532405, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.45160870011971677, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.432097292787772, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.42680595528019055, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4181010581915656, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6821917183639757, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.585877053206817, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5301888577390593, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4996988854338005, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.486974304749821, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.47815676262446527, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.47571545684561445, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7302267592251964, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6466978101441614, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5798380122180012, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5500608881317426, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5422314663775382, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5298682436662951, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.5143241749296004, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 70.78% of these modeled runs. This is a favorable social setting, with low preference for separation and low polarization. It should not be mistaken for an adversarial test of hostility.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 70.78% of these modeled runs. This is a favorable social setting, with low preference for separation and low polarization. It should not be mistaken for an adversarial test of hostility."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-11", "source_scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "name": {"plain": "Deep social separation", "technical": "Low integration and homophily"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.3, "syn_g": 0.012, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.55, "prod": 0.38, "returns": 0.3, "hom": 0.9, "attacks": 0.18, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.1, "ext": 0.12, "capacity": 0.8, "private": 0.34, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.52, "polar": 0.82}, "focus_parameters": ["hom", "polar"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.769, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.618, "free_integrated_rate": 0.009125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.174125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.518, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0035, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.02025, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10425, "avg_liberty": 0.7186675800160113, "avg_individuality": 0.7336052527251581, "avg_integration": 0.29585902104211675, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6014061165524547, "avg_resilience": 0.5588949866825148, "avg_prosperity": 0.2723849736246774, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8496412354655395, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7403997032626376, "avg_trust": 0.4923851885279702, "avg_inequality": 0.6229861808042285, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9333605580318823, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011695233416425244, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4946725614006322, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5274711332785764, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5029022490810431, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4147394591766621, "score_Stability-first": 0.4725074474113754, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5250015648681947}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.804125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6385, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.184625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.555875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0495, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10625, "avg_liberty": 0.6994179667977797, "avg_individuality": 0.6571742522858509, "avg_integration": 0.12747584444176224, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6272900017741296, "avg_resilience": 0.38495899317378895, "avg_prosperity": 0.2855344509869432, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8160215342003906, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8389338703666511, "avg_trust": 0.4745551708471368, "avg_inequality": 0.6195913550251091, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9316931434684846, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00894779549784074, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.43930737882539617, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.49395050206694646, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4812308899006581, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37988762687043265, "score_Stability-first": 0.4157920191835488, "score_Individuality-first": 0.46855458366956326}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.76325, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.512375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.077625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.24025, "bifurcation_rate": 0.655, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.31875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10425, "avg_liberty": 0.5777659171037463, "avg_individuality": 0.5783164824639779, "avg_integration": 0.08517073031162087, "avg_legitimacy": 0.603213843703569, "avg_resilience": 0.3312577556191497, "avg_prosperity": 0.28718884659558636, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7265030185188736, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8805754168489316, "avg_trust": 0.43994207758217474, "avg_inequality": 0.5895964043669986, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9295339168389442, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01088607736904983, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3423912086311265, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.3903475493087021, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.39653606780665374, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3076787777786817, "score_Stability-first": 0.33505939174007837, "score_Individuality-first": 0.3637904737236408}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.53, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.41075, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.180875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.86125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.004625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.101, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.090625, "avg_liberty": 0.5624781826664854, "avg_individuality": 0.5601369196092149, "avg_integration": 0.07140637169182609, "avg_legitimacy": 0.41659677446368526, "avg_resilience": 0.35821595560691266, "avg_prosperity": 0.20168635277968536, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7346408105805776, "avg_governance_eff": 0.4280108911034498, "avg_trust": 0.34221710681878287, "avg_inequality": 0.5245569782265369, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9426921824430772, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00723819142474702, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.2524920815640784, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.29615626081253615, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.25451832424191445, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.185941696003399, "score_Stability-first": 0.21985912767502053, "score_Individuality-first": 0.28580835883103634}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.624875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.477875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.196625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.892375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.004625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.185625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.09625, "avg_liberty": 0.5889770347233391, "avg_individuality": 0.5927125948159133, "avg_integration": 0.03574961192555825, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4759069174072994, "avg_resilience": 0.4128569457127229, "avg_prosperity": 0.2282104069412116, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7745856875686389, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5756230824570737, "avg_trust": 0.371088332154293, "avg_inequality": 0.557611514337674, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9393024067695213, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.007679311239940385, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.2994683779267713, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.34728835248994516, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3131752274273225, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.24239559062879026, "score_Stability-first": 0.2797081359692565, "score_Individuality-first": 0.32995810628556255}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.645125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.34025, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.405875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.581625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.003, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.258, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.097375, "avg_liberty": 0.493172125919126, "avg_individuality": 0.6420601288803881, "avg_integration": 0.14497236857578424, "avg_legitimacy": 0.42418670133979, "avg_resilience": 0.4881472849191804, "avg_prosperity": 0.26838964495190826, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7357637587595666, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8149316059880958, "avg_trust": 0.3365147978988023, "avg_inequality": 0.55599745688058, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9284917633158454, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009716573043198796, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3127790375950429, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.3388825736679505, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.31827369860513344, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.27873016635067704, "score_Stability-first": 0.313979413107459, "score_Individuality-first": 0.33836332644289524}, {"scenario": "11 Low integration and homophily", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.751875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.483, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.056625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.28125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.657, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.358625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.103875, "avg_liberty": 0.5870211643802323, "avg_individuality": 0.5937088477547444, "avg_integration": 0.06707426762450888, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5703251938140019, "avg_resilience": 0.31418219168757905, "avg_prosperity": 0.2810757040408384, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7233366213654667, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8761883431871935, "avg_trust": 0.4142366994086442, "avg_inequality": 0.5611567923732822, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9308986818103158, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010616479278931985, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3301897290028887, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.3816214577288938, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.37929889559576735, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.29299349359440746, "score_Stability-first": 0.31677649379365747, "score_Individuality-first": 0.35564627082271416}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4946725614006322, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.43930737882539617, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3423912086311265, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3301897290028887, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3127790375950429, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.2994683779267713, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.2524920815640784, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5274711332785764, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.49395050206694646, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3903475493087021, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3816214577288938, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.34728835248994516, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3388825736679505, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.29615626081253615, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5029022490810431, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4812308899006581, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.39653606780665374, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.37929889559576735, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.31827369860513344, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3131752274273225, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.25451832424191445, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4147394591766621, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.37988762687043265, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3076787777786817, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.29299349359440746, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.27873016635067704, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.24239559062879026, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.185941696003399, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4725074474113754, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4157920191835488, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.33505939174007837, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.31677649379365747, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.313979413107459, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.2797081359692565, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.21985912767502053, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5250015648681947, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.46855458366956326, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3637904737236408, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.35564627082271416, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.33836332644289524, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.32995810628556255, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.28580835883103634, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 0.91% of these modeled runs. PULSE can lead the score ranking while its goal of a free, cooperating society largely fails. Strong preference for separation is a serious warning, not a success to hide behind rank.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 0.91% of these modeled runs. PULSE can lead the score ranking while its goal of a free, cooperating society largely fails. Strong preference for separation is a serious warning, not a success to hide behind rank."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-12", "source_scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "name": {"plain": "Coordinated illegal copying", "technical": "Coordinated illicit replication"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.24, "syn_g": 0.014, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.7, "prod": 0.45, "returns": 0.35, "hom": 0.42, "attacks": 0.38, "rogue": 0.95, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.18, "capacity": 0.78, "private": 0.42, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.52, "polar": 0.58}, "focus_parameters": ["rogue", "attacks"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.790375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.632375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.5865, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.178875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00075, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0065, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0065, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121, "avg_liberty": 0.7183765806286283, "avg_individuality": 0.7523276550640994, "avg_integration": 0.5573363756723698, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6265602624502431, "avg_resilience": 0.5983275705226239, "avg_prosperity": 0.29709173040554704, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8492357304037803, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7938542630961003, "avg_trust": 0.5566009620381396, "avg_inequality": 0.5888077950507852, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9658593840605282, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.24199867440707043, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5861067468688369, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5933172578902374, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5847424326905308, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.494628552937343, "score_Stability-first": 0.5613955505677688, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6094050870131331}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.81575, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.64025, "free_integrated_rate": 0.144, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.1895, "bifurcation_rate": 0.002375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01325, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.012625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12375, "avg_liberty": 0.6960392420553055, "avg_individuality": 0.669432106057485, "avg_integration": 0.3928998832383014, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6432669948236057, "avg_resilience": 0.4080809468854609, "avg_prosperity": 0.30571920770050454, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7928063429853982, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8712997448613548, "avg_trust": 0.5354632792095749, "avg_inequality": 0.5812242734226345, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9655089403194047, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.24029658206253174, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.521841907657648, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5510366312518781, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5536265792564877, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4503673791611353, "score_Stability-first": 0.4934060468511317, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5449096599801527}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.78125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.555, "free_integrated_rate": 0.014, "domination_rate": 0.0075, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2515, "bifurcation_rate": 0.004875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000375, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01325, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.04675, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121375, "avg_liberty": 0.5771739218330091, "avg_individuality": 0.5896692298378654, "avg_integration": 0.3444508322402272, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6148041616769867, "avg_resilience": 0.35022695000166104, "avg_prosperity": 0.30601373911839114, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6783821029040562, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8892619138759926, "avg_trust": 0.4980242758001556, "avg_inequality": 0.5530224944313253, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9645720045846211, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.28879098209403203, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.43529404806189076, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4591145226910197, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4787721340701574, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38907699083513403, "score_Stability-first": 0.42190961599101295, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4516392943861488}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.587875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.452125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.043, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.18925, "bifurcation_rate": 0.087625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.008, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.014, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.106625, "avg_liberty": 0.5771488393625438, "avg_individuality": 0.5880758642846495, "avg_integration": 0.3031601807899308, "avg_legitimacy": 0.45484474730936414, "avg_resilience": 0.3905306674412243, "avg_prosperity": 0.22786189962047482, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7564163544632654, "avg_governance_eff": 0.49841175951051536, "avg_trust": 0.41031749119770267, "avg_inequality": 0.5101590218118325, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9712126217328713, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.19724057894236996, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3760291573756577, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.39885544745535195, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3719866398800369, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.29738751165177985, "score_Stability-first": 0.33973133297504043, "score_Individuality-first": 0.403851938125785}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.67875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.514125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.002, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.205875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.17275, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0095, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.022875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11275, "avg_liberty": 0.6016818370211479, "avg_individuality": 0.6169724612132327, "avg_integration": 0.257181247552648, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5153019289511083, "avg_resilience": 0.44779018089392747, "avg_prosperity": 0.25668910713089443, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7908201023140402, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6478461187228977, "avg_trust": 0.436719255565263, "avg_inequality": 0.538859823161852, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9692997748946424, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.20839838739762573, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.41500828938268863, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44264107260946495, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.42359600997728764, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.34800761086438214, "score_Stability-first": 0.3931655152358542, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43942933002208384}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.672625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.347875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.019875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4225, "bifurcation_rate": 0.003125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00775, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.031625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.112875, "avg_liberty": 0.4949542172359044, "avg_individuality": 0.6624356955111048, "avg_integration": 0.3912418810812396, "avg_legitimacy": 0.44490514683057353, "avg_resilience": 0.5281442232589614, "avg_prosperity": 0.2929082023457254, "avg_anti_domination": 0.717808560394891, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8353497596745435, "avg_trust": 0.3959630513870448, "avg_inequality": 0.5273913114791032, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9631199116273194, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.2596481678380794, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4018819487599973, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4042557322181415, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3965442557678023, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35686850351809773, "score_Stability-first": 0.3995750783678824, "score_Individuality-first": 0.42193014492015957}, {"scenario": "12 Coordinated illicit replication", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.77025, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.514875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.015125, "domination_rate": 0.007, "authoritarian_rate": 0.289375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.005125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.013375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.055625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12075, "avg_liberty": 0.586437158982155, "avg_individuality": 0.6052602399376059, "avg_integration": 0.3230629331793073, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5827891672068267, "avg_resilience": 0.33101411330077934, "avg_prosperity": 0.3000869545031595, "avg_anti_domination": 0.680080526673187, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8849534861382798, "avg_trust": 0.47170891428038375, "avg_inequality": 0.5249049915461685, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9653444232787961, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.2820530890275265, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42103783520143345, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44870591957869066, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.45973724560274754, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3721248355209585, "score_Stability-first": 0.40127575923250425, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4415540540719871}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5861067468688369, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.521841907657648, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.43529404806189076, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.42103783520143345, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.41500828938268863, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4018819487599973, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3760291573756577, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5933172578902374, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5510366312518781, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4591145226910197, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.44870591957869066, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.44264107260946495, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4042557322181415, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.39885544745535195, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5847424326905308, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5536265792564877, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4787721340701574, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45973724560274754, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.42359600997728764, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3965442557678023, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3719866398800369, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.494628552937343, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4503673791611353, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.38907699083513403, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3721248355209585, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.35686850351809773, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.34800761086438214, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.29738751165177985, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5613955505677688, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4934060468511317, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.42190961599101295, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.40127575923250425, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3995750783678824, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3931655152358542, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.33973133297504043, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6094050870131331, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5449096599801527, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4516392943861488, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4415540540719871, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43942933002208384, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.42193014492015957, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.403851938125785, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 58.65% of these modeled runs. The PULSE branch directly enforces a 30% modeled illegal-origin share cap. Its favorable capture result therefore assumes enforcement; it does not demonstrate that real institutions could enforce the rule.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 58.65% of these modeled runs. The PULSE branch directly enforces a 30% modeled illegal-origin share cap. Its favorable capture result therefore assumes enforcement; it does not demonstrate that real institutions could enforce the rule."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-13", "source_scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "name": {"plain": "Frequent attacks on minds", "technical": "Frequent cognitive attacks"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.32, "syn_g": 0.012, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.3, "tech": 0.75, "prod": 0.48, "returns": 0.32, "hom": 0.36, "attacks": 0.95, "rogue": 0.18, "disaster": 0.14, "ext": 0.25, "capacity": 0.78, "private": 0.42, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.52, "polar": 0.52}, "focus_parameters": ["attacks", "tech"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.802625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.630875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.606875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.191, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.008, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.006125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.13225, "avg_liberty": 0.720714169680948, "avg_individuality": 0.7518496867498875, "avg_integration": 0.5968246069650857, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6388511089113291, "avg_resilience": 0.6083208098832785, "avg_prosperity": 0.3062843754475683, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8611043305385502, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8068184310887214, "avg_trust": 0.573898506631798, "avg_inequality": 0.5944817535669688, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9601882392450535, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.027923308911863436, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5969349876492962, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.600385108488071, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5954532908275526, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5045642810354743, "score_Stability-first": 0.572986155159274, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6181123821341863}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.8245, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.6335, "free_integrated_rate": 0.216, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.201625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.016625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.012, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.134125, "avg_liberty": 0.6950946004610168, "avg_individuality": 0.6597449230621645, "avg_integration": 0.4300537969771876, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6524362979836953, "avg_resilience": 0.4128432584535292, "avg_prosperity": 0.3131027444175425, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8093465807352719, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8792096730613573, "avg_trust": 0.5501861428659393, "avg_inequality": 0.5844917862520425, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9600332009535667, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.021481133468371175, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5284537028199838, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5538072264097285, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5603104710491789, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.45613298096120386, "score_Stability-first": 0.5007719456623951, "score_Individuality-first": 0.548631198711018}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.78875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.54625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.010375, "domination_rate": 0.0015, "authoritarian_rate": 0.267125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.001875, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.017125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.030125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.132, "avg_liberty": 0.5732785638375884, "avg_individuality": 0.5754912396503824, "avg_integration": 0.3808574524634923, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6222048286849817, "avg_resilience": 0.3540088837026208, "avg_prosperity": 0.31260823678865796, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7076690734487493, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8929892053475517, "avg_trust": 0.5115407446878752, "avg_inequality": 0.5557596195098936, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9590665965790319, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.02608827922748047, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4415877108505424, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.461169395479728, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.48469957387894014, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3939138247072952, "score_Stability-first": 0.42887712898112706, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4545089012453971}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.598125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.445375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0805, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.203, "bifurcation_rate": 0.030875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0105, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.013, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1165, "avg_liberty": 0.5782784211793777, "avg_individuality": 0.582813184836389, "avg_integration": 0.3367185604150895, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4650528380179573, "avg_resilience": 0.396733297734947, "avg_prosperity": 0.23515708002245525, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7660873153621591, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5106679664257686, "avg_trust": 0.42488718847053886, "avg_inequality": 0.5147567420969451, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9668062873161328, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01742155530707439, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.38718066516367955, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.40677062280098564, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3835634770817601, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3081481774555922, "score_Stability-first": 0.35182911052722693, "score_Individuality-first": 0.41267403659148016}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.686875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.505625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.008875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.217875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.06775, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0185, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.12325, "avg_liberty": 0.601708750050879, "avg_individuality": 0.6107318344601459, "avg_integration": 0.29202670468328934, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5260276820664306, "avg_resilience": 0.45487628609916475, "avg_prosperity": 0.2644706272970728, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8015829410620561, "avg_governance_eff": 0.661040207235837, "avg_trust": 0.4516757483438604, "avg_inequality": 0.543553391505777, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9645681672326339, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.018470059791390683, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4298510053144594, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4539571342781141, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.43892179405048504, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.36263774627456846, "score_Stability-first": 0.4092682733144716, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4516795914584171}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.674125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.335375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.017625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.43525, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.023125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1235, "avg_liberty": 0.4898719504556675, "avg_individuality": 0.6559130885154052, "avg_integration": 0.425465601004147, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4508208727100555, "avg_resilience": 0.5350057064018995, "avg_prosperity": 0.29959470722921144, "avg_anti_domination": 0.73557457801807, "avg_governance_eff": 0.839042304652957, "avg_trust": 0.4080973532072717, "avg_inequality": 0.5299600530829337, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9570746724213308, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.02331522686055417, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4065998940247406, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.40485347248500225, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.40038724521108104, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3606957309461365, "score_Stability-first": 0.4050965184239923, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4242392324876062}, {"scenario": "13 Frequent cognitive attacks", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.77825, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.500875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.02125, "domination_rate": 0.000875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.30975, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000125, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.017125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0345, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.131375, "avg_liberty": 0.582242681327378, "avg_individuality": 0.5936247152126037, "avg_integration": 0.35928969421466694, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5900697087252621, "avg_resilience": 0.3345442198534124, "avg_prosperity": 0.3068159086011888, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7070568530747277, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8889367050664245, "avg_trust": 0.48519868292348267, "avg_inequality": 0.5277670317690908, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9599783423905628, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.025446446287915273, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42619249425391226, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44967174509580377, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.46443827033383556, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3758236603074694, "score_Stability-first": 0.40692851866710644, "score_Individuality-first": 0.443646915162917}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5969349876492962, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5284537028199838, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4415877108505424, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4298510053144594, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.42619249425391226, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4065998940247406, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38718066516367955, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.600385108488071, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5538072264097285, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.461169395479728, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4539571342781141, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.44967174509580377, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.40677062280098564, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.40485347248500225, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5954532908275526, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5603104710491789, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.48469957387894014, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.46443827033383556, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43892179405048504, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.40038724521108104, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3835634770817601, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5045642810354743, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.45613298096120386, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3939138247072952, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3758236603074694, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.36263774627456846, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3606957309461365, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3081481774555922, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.572986155159274, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5007719456623951, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.42887712898112706, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4092682733144716, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.40692851866710644, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4050965184239923, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.35182911052722693, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6181123821341863, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.548631198711018, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4545089012453971, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4516795914584171, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.443646915162917, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4242392324876062, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.41267403659148016, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 60.69% of these modeled runs. Protection from attacks on minds depends on assumed technical defenses and institutional quality. These outcomes do not validate real restoration or forensic technology.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 60.69% of these modeled runs. Protection from attacks on minds depends on assumed technical defenses and institutional quality. These outcomes do not validate real restoration or forensic technology."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-14", "source_scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "name": {"plain": "A few providers control essential infrastructure", "technical": "Private infrastructure concentration"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.26, "syn_g": 0.014, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.32, "tech": 0.68, "prod": 0.55, "returns": 0.62, "hom": 0.35, "attacks": 0.22, "rogue": 0.12, "disaster": 0.14, "ext": 0.14, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.95, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.55, "polar": 0.45}, "focus_parameters": ["private", "returns"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.8165, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.632, "free_integrated_rate": 0.618625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.007625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.004125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1665, "avg_liberty": 0.7503221561626386, "avg_individuality": 0.7669844116395113, "avg_integration": 0.6184595029740804, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6595114069747856, "avg_resilience": 0.6050217063752912, "avg_prosperity": 0.30022504563943564, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8694157732494154, "avg_governance_eff": 0.824565517005276, "avg_trust": 0.5695330343407653, "avg_inequality": 0.4006534623344677, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9665386044676113, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.016240009866042283, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6043729812027193, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6072896198271989, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6024240318478705, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5014249116788896, "score_Stability-first": 0.5743405791126278, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6246882042149622}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.83275, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.629125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.26275, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.214125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.014625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.008375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.16875, "avg_liberty": 0.7193407823893364, "avg_individuality": 0.6727344070050979, "avg_integration": 0.44155700340369275, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6679294852600076, "avg_resilience": 0.4060394692352746, "avg_prosperity": 0.3039723680237735, "avg_anti_domination": 0.800594221688003, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8918642973981521, "avg_trust": 0.5402482064347669, "avg_inequality": 0.3853415503289549, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9666433176234385, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01226379317098074, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5279847190145671, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5533616076421242, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5596431513360316, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4465325139258787, "score_Stability-first": 0.4947420423333507, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5477561000235663}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.789625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.528, "free_integrated_rate": 0.018, "domination_rate": 0.00625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.283375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00025, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0155, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.034375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.165375, "avg_liberty": 0.5925053280902441, "avg_individuality": 0.5869691862965795, "avg_integration": 0.3883814870605668, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6316557199722859, "avg_resilience": 0.3452116237541907, "avg_prosperity": 0.3002057578528937, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6762670522362012, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8947784572728142, "avg_trust": 0.4975138070506068, "avg_inequality": 0.3577824733154945, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.966234261102526, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.015075728335502204, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.431528686738612, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.451205238544218, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.47410933122670507, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.37594938032242853, "score_Stability-first": 0.4135728169016323, "score_Individuality-first": 0.44467040211023634}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.612625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.446125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.09825, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.215875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.026125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01075, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00975, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.150625, "avg_liberty": 0.6032839503315832, "avg_individuality": 0.5980815517805926, "avg_integration": 0.3488434050918194, "avg_legitimacy": 0.48221097579296257, "avg_resilience": 0.39385357550534855, "avg_prosperity": 0.23026614383377983, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7761481211815208, "avg_governance_eff": 0.523929746539239, "avg_trust": 0.420003617978181, "avg_inequality": 0.34569791337742845, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9718096935812677, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009799244616054942, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.39363706836244355, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4132939792403832, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3894632155650351, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3055231306409283, "score_Stability-first": 0.3528792814967464, "score_Individuality-first": 0.41879358830228647}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.698125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.501875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.010375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.233625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.06575, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.011375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.015125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.15725, "avg_liberty": 0.6257060625992584, "avg_individuality": 0.6238271522651186, "avg_integration": 0.30042903156488715, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5419780424715018, "avg_resilience": 0.4491469496811172, "avg_prosperity": 0.2576968929301707, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8064229688406271, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6740183300887082, "avg_trust": 0.44364520615473096, "avg_inequality": 0.36137551915533944, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9700694246807492, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.010432466369955696, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.43222574326593943, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4566397015791184, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4410451376175655, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35604501576453357, "score_Stability-first": 0.4062074194187344, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45362976847191394}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.68425, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.324875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.053375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.452625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.009, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.01975, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.157625, "avg_liberty": 0.5114665727804085, "avg_individuality": 0.6698716050448437, "avg_integration": 0.4381161552978623, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4614185615531264, "avg_resilience": 0.5314740332929482, "avg_prosperity": 0.29242769888205383, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7257985390621886, "avg_governance_eff": 0.84537145070088, "avg_trust": 0.39715076431843876, "avg_inequality": 0.34719192238755603, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9642867489246519, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013372015619990896, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4048176110356656, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.40278875160703476, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3972157413098235, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3506058504478776, "score_Stability-first": 0.39799924011122645, "score_Individuality-first": 0.42234218529805967}, {"scenario": "14 Private infrastructure concentration", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7785, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.4785, "free_integrated_rate": 0.024125, "domination_rate": 0.005875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.333625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0155, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.043375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.16475, "avg_liberty": 0.6014230868255069, "avg_individuality": 0.5997779777298726, "avg_integration": 0.366182569201026, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5972658908432458, "avg_resilience": 0.32353153515576405, "avg_prosperity": 0.2920203404114834, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6767906394340687, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8908790669096216, "avg_trust": 0.46981935562415333, "avg_inequality": 0.32998228178663147, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9672894076066095, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014684281054334425, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4137444823279654, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.437360126749818, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.45163089676440243, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35538319415015085, "score_Stability-first": 0.38933480846886, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43096356386322804}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6043729812027193, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5279847190145671, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43222574326593943, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.431528686738612, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4137444823279654, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4048176110356656, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.39363706836244355, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6072896198271989, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5533616076421242, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4566397015791184, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.451205238544218, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.437360126749818, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4132939792403832, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.40278875160703476, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6024240318478705, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5596431513360316, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.47410933122670507, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.45163089676440243, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4410451376175655, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3972157413098235, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3894632155650351, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5014249116788896, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4465325139258787, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.37594938032242853, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.35604501576453357, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.35538319415015085, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3506058504478776, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3055231306409283, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5743405791126278, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4947420423333507, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4135728169016323, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4062074194187344, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.39799924011122645, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.38933480846886, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3528792814967464, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6246882042149622, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5477561000235663, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.45362976847191394, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44467040211023634, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.43096356386322804, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.42234218529805967, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.41879358830228647, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 61.86% of these modeled runs. Dependence on private providers is represented by simplified indices. A low recorded private-control event rate is not proof that concentrated infrastructure is harmless.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 61.86% of these modeled runs. Dependence on private providers is represented by simplified indices. A low recorded private-control event rate is not proof that concentrated infrastructure is harmless."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-15", "source_scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "name": {"plain": "Repeated conflict with outside powers", "technical": "Repeated external conflict"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.3, "syn_g": 0.01, "org_g": -0.001, "scarcity": 0.44, "tech": 0.62, "prod": 0.4, "returns": 0.25, "hom": 0.38, "attacks": 0.42, "rogue": 0.15, "disaster": 0.22, "ext": 0.95, "capacity": 0.76, "private": 0.4, "planets": 0.1, "abundance": 0.42, "polar": 0.5}, "focus_parameters": ["ext", "scarcity"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.778625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.604375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.56975, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.195875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0005, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.020625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1845, "avg_liberty": 0.7004667989416213, "avg_individuality": 0.7461880747290652, "avg_integration": 0.570290514615308, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6191508015539102, "avg_resilience": 0.5864393015559254, "avg_prosperity": 0.2711073121917659, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8487732060044576, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7880353435478977, "avg_trust": 0.5534452965827168, "avg_inequality": 0.6119342689448156, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9217217809872309, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.019761695355075645, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5737145105017499, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5778100047687744, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5720641601867108, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.477510876554578, "score_Stability-first": 0.5484130445939254, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5976934661477447}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.80775, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.613625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.194875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.206625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.014375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0395, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.188125, "avg_liberty": 0.6806193464731143, "avg_individuality": 0.6692202822192176, "avg_integration": 0.41206142826780967, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6372234060441454, "avg_resilience": 0.40146084819638755, "avg_prosperity": 0.27887540154589774, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8086567362576474, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8657180476961476, "avg_trust": 0.5345493514756677, "avg_inequality": 0.6063440298668793, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9211116964135141, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.015167044873081195, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5153478833908393, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5407472848388645, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5455809323820122, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.43695738975648835, "score_Stability-first": 0.4856049999708475, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5393634838381179}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.767, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.525375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.022, "domination_rate": 0.003, "authoritarian_rate": 0.26775, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000375, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.016625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.076, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.185, "avg_liberty": 0.5605866145100531, "avg_individuality": 0.5885806849407557, "avg_integration": 0.36298870700151153, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6068843101164293, "avg_resilience": 0.3434127531986535, "avg_prosperity": 0.2779486392052803, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7142603225294754, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8808509246408265, "avg_trust": 0.4957817141407517, "avg_inequality": 0.5753940235445623, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9196640716013739, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.018411183680662198, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.43031725995834996, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.45001995215869633, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.471294016525231, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3755802525232902, "score_Stability-first": 0.4149459860558407, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4474153505248763}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.565875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.4195, "free_integrated_rate": 0.059125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.202375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.040375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.010375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.041625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.164625, "avg_liberty": 0.5590365982702943, "avg_individuality": 0.5822373386257607, "avg_integration": 0.3171579227249419, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4466570354511486, "avg_resilience": 0.3809089322704619, "avg_prosperity": 0.20674578848497566, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7491017444267452, "avg_governance_eff": 0.49324594295772867, "avg_trust": 0.40643286653471, "avg_inequality": 0.5264527236197787, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9319788500963184, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012318629120225435, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3658725757410555, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.38551087005941, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3613266907968731, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.2839541794373138, "score_Stability-first": 0.32942832166254454, "score_Individuality-first": 0.39413602555712446}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.65625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.47975, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0045, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.2205, "bifurcation_rate": 0.089625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.05825, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.174625, "avg_liberty": 0.5820686303061897, "avg_individuality": 0.6109046087743899, "avg_integration": 0.2740976596973838, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5059181634517156, "avg_resilience": 0.4367719597827507, "avg_prosperity": 0.2326912426369794, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7856404338069489, "avg_governance_eff": 0.640663300440406, "avg_trust": 0.4325512049234034, "avg_inequality": 0.5564726782474274, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9280103091564449, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01305472981952792, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.40716431122805563, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4311570669618584, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4149096167190939, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3359452583979445, "score_Stability-first": 0.3847896714087079, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43214433179087286}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.650375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.327875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.429, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00725, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.066125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.176, "avg_liberty": 0.47767789074085454, "avg_individuality": 0.6556361861421903, "avg_integration": 0.4050333278854239, "avg_legitimacy": 0.43876026479153807, "avg_resilience": 0.5154406386546518, "avg_prosperity": 0.26565188588350086, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7309298673850911, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8245579953815061, "avg_trust": 0.39393306440014436, "avg_inequality": 0.5463145306735945, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9170856090889627, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.016464601168449146, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3930984363656924, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.39215840733157614, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.38704835091693746, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.34168661399916833, "score_Stability-first": 0.3894135730297873, "score_Individuality-first": 0.41370487383014987}, {"scenario": "15 Repeated external conflict", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.756625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.48975, "free_integrated_rate": 0.022375, "domination_rate": 0.001625, "authoritarian_rate": 0.306375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.001875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.016125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.08575, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.1835, "avg_liberty": 0.569994889062373, "avg_individuality": 0.6044835615556108, "avg_integration": 0.34213752873006703, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5760562359215403, "avg_resilience": 0.3250949527168514, "avg_prosperity": 0.2726827195427904, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7128829888419832, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8772234315963854, "avg_trust": 0.47055375521035836, "avg_inequality": 0.5483164843039249, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9209045173329442, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.017957784703592203, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.41710720023911974, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44063362741878787, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4535313584946984, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.36001653416278534, "score_Stability-first": 0.3956195572410939, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43834574913239444}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5737145105017499, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5153478833908393, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.43031725995834996, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.41710720023911974, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.40716431122805563, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3930984363656924, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3658725757410555, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5778100047687744, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5407472848388645, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.45001995215869633, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.44063362741878787, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4311570669618584, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.39215840733157614, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38551087005941, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5720641601867108, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5455809323820122, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.471294016525231, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4535313584946984, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4149096167190939, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.38704835091693746, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3613266907968731, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.477510876554578, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.43695738975648835, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3755802525232902, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.36001653416278534, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.34168661399916833, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3359452583979445, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.2839541794373138, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5484130445939254, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4856049999708475, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4149459860558407, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3956195572410939, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3894135730297873, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3847896714087079, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.32942832166254454, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5976934661477447, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5393634838381179, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4474153505248763, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.43834574913239444, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.43214433179087286, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.41370487383014987, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.39413602555712446, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 56.97% of these modeled runs. Outside conflict adds disruption and emergency pressure. This is not a military forecast and does not model specific states or weapons.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 56.97% of these modeled runs. Outside conflict adds disruption and emergency pressure. This is not a military forecast and does not model specific states or weapons."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-16", "source_scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "name": {"plain": "A catastrophe targets one population", "technical": "Species-targeted catastrophe"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.34, "syn_g": 0.01, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.36, "tech": 0.62, "prod": 0.42, "returns": 0.28, "hom": 0.32, "attacks": 0.35, "rogue": 0.12, "disaster": 0.95, "ext": 0.32, "capacity": 0.78, "private": 0.38, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.48, "polar": 0.42}, "focus_parameters": ["disaster", "capacity"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.79975, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.617375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.60375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.184625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.028125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.499125, "avg_liberty": 0.7217742719107517, "avg_individuality": 0.7691817185301594, "avg_integration": 0.621657742364613, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6499969754761914, "avg_resilience": 0.58933339529201, "avg_prosperity": 0.28551656851063, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8633166466031487, "avg_governance_eff": 0.811613351056682, "avg_trust": 0.5864379864194921, "avg_inequality": 0.6217875983632117, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8954823491398936, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01511765230426118, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5988081387672967, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6007650859940898, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5985769694184109, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.49805103724573185, "score_Stability-first": 0.5701891167953306, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6232710963244894}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.821125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.60725, "free_integrated_rate": 0.3245, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.193375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.05575, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.01375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.504, "avg_liberty": 0.6974958606406584, "avg_individuality": 0.6881468379000997, "avg_integration": 0.457060341839633, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6638429360766119, "avg_resilience": 0.39134673110212553, "avg_prosperity": 0.28968083205336737, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8188813611487126, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8831554105044369, "avg_trust": 0.5635461542928925, "avg_inequality": 0.6131363471259671, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.895951224396198, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011602165534871936, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5305521176859205, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5544528766931651, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5627463078072337, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4473837934926373, "score_Stability-first": 0.49627761558751066, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5555868119761544}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.784625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.52725, "free_integrated_rate": 0.058625, "domination_rate": 0.001375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.251875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.05675, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.029125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.497375, "avg_liberty": 0.5755821729054764, "avg_individuality": 0.6058273100418078, "avg_integration": 0.40593379411321917, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6297856042870311, "avg_resilience": 0.3311207277299014, "avg_prosperity": 0.2872301849617721, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7227190747305008, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8898060209420887, "avg_trust": 0.5221300191220484, "avg_inequality": 0.5816029239286922, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8953132466943413, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014083133413919811, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4450814738380001, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.46334815195095036, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4874167042569181, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.38536372963732823, "score_Stability-first": 0.4247256816467797, "score_Individuality-first": 0.463423678190627}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.60825, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.43725, "free_integrated_rate": 0.135125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.196375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.008, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.04175, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.01475, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.450375, "avg_liberty": 0.5836388181911495, "avg_individuality": 0.6096686882170064, "avg_integration": 0.36219397037381595, "avg_legitimacy": 0.47926243851872513, "avg_resilience": 0.38091292511191865, "avg_prosperity": 0.22022436300876286, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7731359658052336, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5212572210381256, "avg_trust": 0.4399719889210167, "avg_inequality": 0.5428685193507015, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9111738324477004, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009418505843365434, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.3966744044617482, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4152325942922127, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.393980763276638, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.30931153048709825, "score_Stability-first": 0.3560900210348631, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4261654934068758}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.696375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.49525, "free_integrated_rate": 0.022375, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.210875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.02075, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.045125, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.021, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.473875, "avg_liberty": 0.6054271873744131, "avg_individuality": 0.6369862184269227, "avg_integration": 0.3175154188315526, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5391044779502289, "avg_resilience": 0.437021286407473, "avg_prosperity": 0.24726681290118882, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8072124326533178, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6703619438744588, "avg_trust": 0.4656548209901771, "avg_inequality": 0.5710343388169554, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9054181481774545, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009982482267749332, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.439557568504021, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4624966445230326, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4495353807999853, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3636607007866266, "score_Stability-first": 0.41355832620063143, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4655150657447668}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.68525, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.330875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0245, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.4325, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0305, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.02375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.475125, "avg_liberty": 0.496198954132272, "avg_individuality": 0.6807132609057054, "avg_integration": 0.45222959202440327, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4622739696557261, "avg_resilience": 0.5191608591719593, "avg_prosperity": 0.2804201699690063, "avg_anti_domination": 0.748298048638605, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8429074067637227, "avg_trust": 0.4217640793538765, "avg_inequality": 0.5584950060835168, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8921741582014452, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01259062043896458, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4150252189591267, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.41205246416191976, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.40890572427847627, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3592834938642173, "score_Stability-first": 0.4076835038190706, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4366579356630764}, {"scenario": "16 Species-targeted catastrophe", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.77475, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.487125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.068, "domination_rate": 0.00025, "authoritarian_rate": 0.293875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.057, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.031625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.495375, "avg_liberty": 0.5850689830245352, "avg_individuality": 0.6217922383505098, "avg_integration": 0.38447551790508955, "avg_legitimacy": 0.598152301514198, "avg_resilience": 0.3119993066449355, "avg_prosperity": 0.2816538929642843, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7213117359701489, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8861473827590571, "avg_trust": 0.49613175953241906, "avg_inequality": 0.5537535545319933, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8969681333790269, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013737225863175212, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4305895252302533, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4527749911819753, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.46830413851382524, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.36845344123363655, "score_Stability-first": 0.4039644763267849, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4531523326471235}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5988081387672967, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5305521176859205, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4450814738380001, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.439557568504021, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4305895252302533, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4150252189591267, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3966744044617482, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6007650859940898, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5544528766931651, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46334815195095036, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4624966445230326, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4527749911819753, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4152325942922127, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.41205246416191976, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5985769694184109, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5627463078072337, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4874167042569181, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.46830413851382524, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4495353807999853, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.40890572427847627, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.393980763276638, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.49805103724573185, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.4473837934926373, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.38536372963732823, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.36845344123363655, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3636607007866266, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3592834938642173, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.30931153048709825, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5701891167953306, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.49627761558751066, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4247256816467797, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.41355832620063143, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4076835038190706, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4039644763267849, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3560900210348631, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6232710963244894, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5555868119761544, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4655150657447668, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.463423678190627, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4531523326471235, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4366579356630764, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4261654934068758, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 60.38% of these modeled runs. The label describes a stress setting with a high disaster input. The model includes both species-targeted and common-mode hazards; this is not an isolated test of only one event type.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 60.38% of these modeled runs. The label describes a stress setting with a high disaster input. The model includes both species-targeted and common-mode hazards; this is not an isolated test of only one event type."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-17", "source_scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "name": {"plain": "A catastrophe threatens shared systems", "technical": "Common-mode catastrophe"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.3, "syn_g": 0.01, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.42, "tech": 0.6, "prod": 0.4, "returns": 0.28, "hom": 0.34, "attacks": 0.48, "rogue": 0.12, "disaster": 0.88, "ext": 0.42, "capacity": 0.74, "private": 0.5, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.42, "polar": 0.48}, "focus_parameters": ["disaster", "private"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.784125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.58825, "free_integrated_rate": 0.56, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.20825, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.025625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0105, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.502375, "avg_liberty": 0.693209491742605, "avg_individuality": 0.7424890590673243, "avg_integration": 0.5905981160606729, "avg_legitimacy": 0.622996725803042, "avg_resilience": 0.5564898631751679, "avg_prosperity": 0.2676859261063377, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8492180578152957, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7896916740313225, "avg_trust": 0.5561737232453128, "avg_inequality": 0.5870472591021108, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8755467672266017, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014612629372574858, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5664308845137107, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5689776281554569, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5663798965004558, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4668692373549579, "score_Stability-first": 0.537114760636007, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5906758178373305}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.816375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.590375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.24575, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.21975, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.045625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.018, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.5125, "avg_liberty": 0.6765393220514754, "avg_individuality": 0.668219302628738, "avg_integration": 0.43640879206603755, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6433441046324435, "avg_resilience": 0.3757396958499667, "avg_prosperity": 0.27369992873783283, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8102096454664234, "avg_governance_eff": 0.869880766706081, "avg_trust": 0.539719803362332, "avg_inequality": 0.5825801546267488, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.875052255866932, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011272226081897607, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5090176889812402, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5325929362748631, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5406846862147277, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.42636619669008713, "score_Stability-first": 0.47533593749396574, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5333483976996685}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.77975, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.508, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0235, "domination_rate": 0.0085, "authoritarian_rate": 0.279375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00075, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000375, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.046625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.04225, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.502625, "avg_liberty": 0.5590784079052453, "avg_individuality": 0.58904326928203, "avg_integration": 0.38804792665986965, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6150805399357564, "avg_resilience": 0.31989254061866257, "avg_prosperity": 0.2727655026249989, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7159958504441183, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8881236398689664, "avg_trust": 0.5027327627766351, "avg_inequality": 0.553578375654457, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8740048298996514, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013635178735409998, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.42682738869305664, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.44482896852821946, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4694587984504643, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3676956573976752, "score_Stability-first": 0.40768933816171543, "score_Individuality-first": 0.44424351102031007}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.57475, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.400875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.08575, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.221, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0265, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.033, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.019875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.451125, "avg_liberty": 0.5551336289644988, "avg_individuality": 0.5811402788097932, "avg_integration": 0.33776108342199124, "avg_legitimacy": 0.45280270784856513, "avg_resilience": 0.358814507252426, "avg_prosperity": 0.2038266582967332, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7514581375344562, "avg_governance_eff": 0.4973467395348857, "avg_trust": 0.4107899069527819, "avg_inequality": 0.506232707869406, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8912340166749564, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00919596314343377, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.36200509903531886, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.38009662452163495, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.35884087628552097, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.276750007951582, "score_Stability-first": 0.3222968261218371, "score_Individuality-first": 0.3904185535369965}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.665375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.458625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.01, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.23725, "bifurcation_rate": 0.05925, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.037, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.030375, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.474875, "avg_liberty": 0.5787793511304578, "avg_individuality": 0.610568091408227, "avg_integration": 0.29720421939369485, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5130058886485169, "avg_resilience": 0.41328979739978955, "avg_prosperity": 0.22985320096917325, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7888519289646667, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6459016350419758, "avg_trust": 0.4379928884251909, "avg_inequality": 0.5356076412401697, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8859937884548087, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009733803112844247, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4046998273672756, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4270415915578646, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.413912477995373, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3297609341672803, "score_Stability-first": 0.37870957622037926, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4298965791214229}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.6655, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.31675, "free_integrated_rate": 0.00975, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.44325, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00025, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.027375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.03425, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.477375, "avg_liberty": 0.4759483633238421, "avg_individuality": 0.65586119305968, "avg_integration": 0.42765009054880454, "avg_legitimacy": 0.44732495429604857, "avg_resilience": 0.49185256338033206, "avg_prosperity": 0.2632521451201753, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7332395636807503, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8311622416221489, "avg_trust": 0.4004886550159579, "avg_inequality": 0.5255099630911352, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8715151790402207, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01222300101602082, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.39086912036902755, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.38851629774438745, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.3865977144864723, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.33578709312322047, "score_Stability-first": 0.3835474345900075, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4117319618493652}, {"scenario": "17 Common-mode catastrophe", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7695, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.47, "free_integrated_rate": 0.03075, "domination_rate": 0.005125, "authoritarian_rate": 0.318875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.000625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.000125, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.046875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.047125, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.501125, "avg_liberty": 0.5689577638775886, "avg_individuality": 0.6050109848195034, "avg_integration": 0.3673268716836195, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5847094670077287, "avg_resilience": 0.30181209996634734, "avg_prosperity": 0.2673884226763879, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7148355345428448, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8849479297820754, "avg_trust": 0.4778732332740666, "avg_inequality": 0.5269886951913425, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.8758812932936222, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013304423522096898, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4133520163486234, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.43520190872754605, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4514988180849291, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.35181067595064197, "score_Stability-first": 0.38811855089017944, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43489424823500555}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5664308845137107, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5090176889812402, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.42682738869305664, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4133520163486234, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4046998273672756, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.39086912036902755, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.36200509903531886, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5689776281554569, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5325929362748631, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44482896852821946, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.43520190872754605, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4270415915578646, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.38851629774438745, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.38009662452163495, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5663798965004558, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5406846862147277, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4694587984504643, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4514988180849291, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.413912477995373, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3865977144864723, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.35884087628552097, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.4668692373549579, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.42636619669008713, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.3676956573976752, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.35181067595064197, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.33578709312322047, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.3297609341672803, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.276750007951582, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.537114760636007, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.47533593749396574, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.40768933816171543, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.38811855089017944, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3835474345900075, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.37870957622037926, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3222968261218371, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5906758178373305, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5333483976996685, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44424351102031007, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.43489424823500555, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4298965791214229, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4117319618493652, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3904185535369965, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 56.00% of these modeled runs. Common failures are especially important when systems share dependencies. This world raises several pressures; the title does not imply a separate physical catastrophe model.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 56.00% of these modeled runs. Common failures are especially important when systems share dependencies. This world raises several pressures; the title does not imply a separate physical catastrophe model."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-18", "source_scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "name": {"plain": "Settlement spreads across planets", "technical": "Interplanetary expansion"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.34, "syn_g": 0.016, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.26, "tech": 0.86, "prod": 0.58, "returns": 0.34, "hom": 0.34, "attacks": 0.22, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.12, "ext": 0.24, "capacity": 0.82, "private": 0.38, "planets": 0.95, "abundance": 0.66, "polar": 0.32}, "focus_parameters": ["planets", "tech"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.81125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.646, "free_integrated_rate": 0.627, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.18425, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.006625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.003, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.119125, "avg_liberty": 0.7523193119840664, "avg_individuality": 0.772169599911464, "avg_integration": 0.607274442294845, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6731667258175376, "avg_resilience": 0.6663523504641456, "avg_prosperity": 0.3371324130165567, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8747024381134525, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8219030981566029, "avg_trust": 0.6032866158837319, "avg_inequality": 0.6019405091012948, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9853286568062968, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014925747930267142, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6266917950089214, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.6305497849380778, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6253147706682666, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5378501851214383, "score_Stability-first": 0.6079687944895397, "score_Individuality-first": 0.645692140488709}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.815875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.63125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.228, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.195875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01775, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.008625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.120875, "avg_liberty": 0.7187759435793669, "avg_individuality": 0.6755296580790604, "avg_integration": 0.4284100426045932, "avg_legitimacy": 0.676350852554845, "avg_resilience": 0.4536844519597405, "avg_prosperity": 0.3397914079209359, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8078696260617817, "avg_governance_eff": 0.872446111628125, "avg_trust": 0.570774963166578, "avg_inequality": 0.5866803379087983, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9856678682386965, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01133354591179132, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.543715011431038, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.570568635097591, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5753218399278858, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.47516925437104107, "score_Stability-first": 0.5192643502628785, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5630318696703308}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.75775, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.532375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.01975, "domination_rate": 0.000375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.257625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.019625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.024875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.11725, "avg_liberty": 0.5884263368289389, "avg_individuality": 0.586964661383048, "avg_integration": 0.37314734673538463, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6368910582167026, "avg_resilience": 0.3815446052762029, "avg_prosperity": 0.3334991931488128, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6857771898606525, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8853010114679584, "avg_trust": 0.5245943347900962, "avg_inequality": 0.5506141005250258, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.985369635676792, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013873667640136795, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.44500156027989296, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.46634501402811906, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4883681563410965, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.40214284127812844, "score_Stability-first": 0.4350915281871223, "score_Individuality-first": 0.45772763711368086}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.581, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.43925, "free_integrated_rate": 0.079875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.197625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.00375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0095, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10475, "avg_liberty": 0.5997503984816803, "avg_individuality": 0.5976999058470621, "avg_integration": 0.3375405893135476, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4889639355530476, "avg_resilience": 0.4320916081437903, "avg_prosperity": 0.2558429338973508, "avg_anti_domination": 0.773582970677293, "avg_governance_eff": 0.5080691718042977, "avg_trust": 0.44489933003230875, "avg_inequality": 0.5182121387308639, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9885398990630259, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009102083754881137, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4039386999839669, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4245775958271468, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4003619150873856, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.32681491118852896, "score_Stability-first": 0.3711264460221216, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4286714949967023}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.709125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.527375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.005875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.216375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.010125, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.013375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.013625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.112625, "avg_liberty": 0.6326448471303552, "avg_individuality": 0.6340917166340662, "avg_integration": 0.2935650520244676, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5615821682872896, "avg_resilience": 0.510408091462224, "avg_prosperity": 0.2935252024415871, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8187414683809594, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6875626907238234, "avg_trust": 0.48047879656311354, "avg_inequality": 0.5546125437559435, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9874078568322684, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009676072180580768, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.465854006609778, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.49120427656651083, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4761120649573946, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4024227738337431, "score_Stability-first": 0.4507866720722325, "score_Individuality-first": 0.48597969641294775}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.654375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.33625, "free_integrated_rate": 0.046625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.42675, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.009, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.015625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.110875, "avg_liberty": 0.5080835422310691, "avg_individuality": 0.6655132634491573, "avg_integration": 0.42366158004750387, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4669149609708767, "avg_resilience": 0.5730233239754903, "avg_prosperity": 0.32183624620026385, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7282850924296377, "avg_governance_eff": 0.837845865815819, "avg_trust": 0.42269992463046113, "avg_inequality": 0.528456576057859, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9841375147713507, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012335380291449554, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4183703649757275, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4175637818285723, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4117403091257897, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3769628101193803, "score_Stability-first": 0.4208185884103069, "score_Individuality-first": 0.43465278739784025}, {"scenario": "18 Interplanetary expansion", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.7515, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.496, "free_integrated_rate": 0.025375, "domination_rate": 0.00025, "authoritarian_rate": 0.298, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.019625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0285, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.117125, "avg_liberty": 0.5986302773440766, "avg_individuality": 0.6034933470333579, "avg_integration": 0.35199082223790173, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6058210748153798, "avg_resilience": 0.36353517326837514, "avg_prosperity": 0.3282441077714609, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6877590434079941, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8851155349390903, "avg_trust": 0.4986779918907285, "avg_inequality": 0.5230590903258396, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9857364959090009, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.013520305540571726, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4324940065914842, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.4577358816882512, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4712693943480908, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.3871433429536193, "score_Stability-first": 0.4164388986324481, "score_Individuality-first": 0.4493333835827834}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6266917950089214, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.543715011431038, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.465854006609778, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.44500156027989296, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4324940065914842, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4183703649757275, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4039386999839669, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6305497849380778, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.570568635097591, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.49120427656651083, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.46634501402811906, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4577358816882512, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4245775958271468, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4175637818285723, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6253147706682666, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5753218399278858, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4883681563410965, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4761120649573946, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4712693943480908, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4117403091257897, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4003619150873856, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.5378501851214383, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.47516925437104107, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4024227738337431, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.40214284127812844, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.3871433429536193, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.3769628101193803, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.32681491118852896, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6079687944895397, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5192643502628785, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.4507866720722325, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4350915281871223, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4208185884103069, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4164388986324481, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.3711264460221216, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.645692140488709, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5630318696703308, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.48597969641294775, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.45772763711368086, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4493333835827834, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.43465278739784025, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4286714949967023, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 62.70% of these modeled runs. Settlement across worlds increases governing and coordination demands over time. Light-speed communications, actual distance and engineering logistics are not explicitly simulated.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 62.70% of these modeled runs. Settlement across worlds increases governing and coordination demands over time. Light-speed communications, actual distance and engineering logistics are not explicitly simulated."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-19", "source_scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "name": {"plain": "Institutions struggle to function", "technical": "Weak institutions"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.25, "syn_g": 0.014, "org_g": 0.0, "scarcity": 0.38, "tech": 0.55, "prod": 0.38, "returns": 0.35, "hom": 0.48, "attacks": 0.38, "rogue": 0.2, "disaster": 0.18, "ext": 0.28, "capacity": 0.32, "private": 0.55, "planets": 0.08, "abundance": 0.42, "polar": 0.68}, "focus_parameters": ["capacity", "polar"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.387875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.23225, "free_integrated_rate": 0.02225, "domination_rate": 0.003875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.289, "bifurcation_rate": 0.03925, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.004, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.009, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.08075, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.121, "avg_liberty": 0.37368433047136207, "avg_individuality": 0.44567606350159683, "avg_integration": 0.29103054287796637, "avg_legitimacy": 0.33753053007972456, "avg_resilience": 0.29552414633898527, "avg_prosperity": 0.1790184218150356, "avg_anti_domination": 0.572035252635171, "avg_governance_eff": 0.49276491190936994, "avg_trust": 0.2948891892489167, "avg_inequality": 0.3809826605110558, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9636419139964337, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.026531317053482818, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.21084149206180086, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.21594570771342114, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.20964854208804862, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.1586601963291468, "score_Stability-first": 0.19190176667691033, "score_Individuality-first": 0.22760600462343122}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.554125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.33225, "free_integrated_rate": 0.001, "domination_rate": 0.012375, "authoritarian_rate": 0.306, "bifurcation_rate": 0.03175, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.00525, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.12325, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.142125, "avg_liberty": 0.43506132072262704, "avg_individuality": 0.4799564422672843, "avg_integration": 0.26027666404612, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4184457691729242, "avg_resilience": 0.262175435435341, "avg_prosperity": 0.2160611665199411, "avg_anti_domination": 0.6271426791466873, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6565525631158337, "avg_trust": 0.34765606702668844, "avg_inequality": 0.43898986090606545, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.961985176460903, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.022356559416039198, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.27052237705642085, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.2877687613655901, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.28979307500378293, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.22228831981796487, "score_Stability-first": 0.25044295785659393, "score_Individuality-first": 0.28838179586046264}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.548625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.263375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.1515, "authoritarian_rate": 0.346, "bifurcation_rate": 0.043625, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.024625, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01425, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.286625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.144, "avg_liberty": 0.3792080950611202, "avg_individuality": 0.45056311612787125, "avg_integration": 0.24245874928221717, "avg_legitimacy": 0.4331209370911249, "avg_resilience": 0.2427902794051749, "avg_prosperity": 0.22523060779401138, "avg_anti_domination": 0.5739607983778462, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7506878700414745, "avg_trust": 0.3486727029674362, "avg_inequality": 0.4345220079184722, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9605722991470106, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.0253232692028557, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.23371156423686604, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.247845087748762, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.26603978910388304, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.2021360959495853, "score_Stability-first": 0.2265434734351965, "score_Individuality-first": 0.2464161967058945}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.165125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.09775, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.00325, "authoritarian_rate": 0.24525, "bifurcation_rate": 0.313, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.018125, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00625, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.182875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.094625, "avg_liberty": 0.2761572521413594, "avg_individuality": 0.31964077313140155, "avg_integration": 0.1524251811539573, "avg_legitimacy": 0.2191652015681121, "avg_resilience": 0.19346265616692204, "avg_prosperity": 0.12096035057450305, "avg_anti_domination": 0.4429606421592795, "avg_governance_eff": 0.2586715900821722, "avg_trust": 0.19370375868500334, "avg_inequality": 0.28703197670340885, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9677833418819066, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.01992599394296756, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.040992019891861214, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.05130681252234884, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.034680906733072475, "score_Capability-utilitarian": -0.0016095955516615135, "score_Stability-first": 0.01958988366489331, "score_Individuality-first": 0.05758580905530117}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.256375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.14875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.00875, "authoritarian_rate": 0.276375, "bifurcation_rate": 0.469875, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.016125, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.008375, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.265875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.10825, "avg_liberty": 0.3125834529889512, "avg_individuality": 0.36630529334623335, "avg_integration": 0.14975444611387198, "avg_legitimacy": 0.27073057860148503, "avg_resilience": 0.23495971776148372, "avg_prosperity": 0.14809345057818188, "avg_anti_domination": 0.5077412254586797, "avg_governance_eff": 0.3823113042523215, "avg_trust": 0.2296103020123009, "avg_inequality": 0.3336801456796846, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9659126129729211, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.020573011933794547, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.08326183401040793, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.09648927043376476, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.08385031180523905, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.042903680167599434, "score_Stability-first": 0.06722936712444866, "score_Individuality-first": 0.09960882712685282}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.34825, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.136875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.0325, "authoritarian_rate": 0.443, "bifurcation_rate": 0.036375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.003875, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00925, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.256, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.120375, "avg_liberty": 0.29164832515043665, "avg_individuality": 0.4285640481557482, "avg_integration": 0.23431206040646718, "avg_legitimacy": 0.2884305369712597, "avg_resilience": 0.2904665464551258, "avg_prosperity": 0.18778620115021044, "avg_anti_domination": 0.5248816266960552, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6015035278133358, "avg_trust": 0.24706158591103683, "avg_inequality": 0.368177551635441, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9611811064075987, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.02372248889485207, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.15900077330967877, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.1613522462232358, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.16127966423818824, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.1296153089964926, "score_Stability-first": 0.15508505577362597, "score_Individuality-first": 0.17300801669913807}, {"scenario": "19 Weak institutions", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.558625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.26125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.0, "domination_rate": 0.12925, "authoritarian_rate": 0.375625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.042375, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.010875, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01425, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.302, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.145, "avg_liberty": 0.393113421587802, "avg_individuality": 0.4673996218423886, "avg_integration": 0.2337720982670803, "avg_legitimacy": 0.42487298047100114, "avg_resilience": 0.23778630952229274, "avg_prosperity": 0.22579224882255172, "avg_anti_domination": 0.5815180762680763, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7711220077616029, "avg_trust": 0.3415685218556588, "avg_inequality": 0.42406294345579626, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9608159654039632, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.024880733666688876, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.23788514105597405, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.25465634024690154, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.26893583238057095, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.20482778093346846, "score_Stability-first": 0.22772388479148878, "score_Individuality-first": 0.25291220552630156}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.27052237705642085, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.23788514105597405, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.23371156423686604, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.21084149206180086, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.15900077330967877, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.08326183401040793, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.040992019891861214, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.2877687613655901, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.25465634024690154, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.247845087748762, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.21594570771342114, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.1613522462232358, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.09648927043376476, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.05130681252234884, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.28979307500378293, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.26893583238057095, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.26603978910388304, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.20964854208804862, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.16127966423818824, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.08385031180523905, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.034680906733072475, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.22228831981796487, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.20482778093346846, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.2021360959495853, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.1586601963291468, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.1296153089964926, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.042903680167599434, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": -0.0016095955516615135, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.25044295785659393, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.22772388479148878, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.2265434734351965, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.19190176667691033, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.15508505577362597, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.06722936712444866, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.01958988366489331, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.28838179586046264, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.25291220552630156, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.2464161967058945, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.22760600462343122, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.17300801669913807, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.09960882712685282, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.05758580905530117, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 4 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 2.23% of these modeled runs. This is the baseline case where PULSE loses under all six value systems. Simpler institutions outperform it when its extra machinery is too difficult to run.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 4 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 2.23% of these modeled runs. This is the baseline case where PULSE loses under all six value systems. Simpler institutions outperform it when its extra machinery is too difficult to run."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["no_catastrophic_failure", "survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity", "avg_legitimacy"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 4, "Classical-liberal": 4, "Procedural-democratic": 4, "Capability-utilitarian": 4, "Stability-first": 4, "Individuality-first": 4}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}, {"id": "world-20", "source_scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "name": {"plain": "Resources become exceptionally abundant", "technical": "Post-scarcity abundance"}, "assumptions": {"s0": 0.38, "syn_g": 0.016, "org_g": 0.001, "scarcity": 0.02, "tech": 0.98, "prod": 0.82, "returns": 0.18, "hom": 0.22, "attacks": 0.18, "rogue": 0.1, "disaster": 0.08, "ext": 0.08, "capacity": 0.9, "private": 0.24, "planets": 0.22, "abundance": 0.98, "polar": 0.15}, "focus_parameters": ["scarcity", "abundance", "tech"], "outcomes": [{"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "PULSE", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.867125, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.722375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.722125, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.15325, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.0055, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0005, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.0935, "avg_liberty": 0.8132316945784577, "avg_individuality": 0.8236658452703921, "avg_integration": 0.7399946178098505, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7381080591115734, "avg_resilience": 0.7216121210333788, "avg_prosperity": 0.4230225274840977, "avg_anti_domination": 0.9086891145959307, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8817396167973639, "avg_trust": 0.6904045696245352, "avg_inequality": 0.7017990410046985, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9889276824706758, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.015656694164347482, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.7106206896467734, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.7093504422409175, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.708673678175989, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.6250517403934855, "score_Stability-first": 0.6909920559875387, "score_Individuality-first": 0.7273155030963586}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.872, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.710875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.622625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.163875, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.013875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.002625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.093875, "avg_liberty": 0.7685792945205153, "avg_individuality": 0.7152451277426706, "avg_integration": 0.5446578829958593, "avg_legitimacy": 0.7352064436340878, "avg_resilience": 0.47872449356310665, "avg_prosperity": 0.42393139818385, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8372813318017082, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9281951038023646, "avg_trust": 0.6497393689504103, "avg_inequality": 0.6821867848624773, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9892319212193422, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.011768976947720038, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.6166872348458063, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.640097577159326, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.6501275422220094, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.5527379935718091, "score_Stability-first": 0.5894838478450911, "score_Individuality-first": 0.6341339229490124}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Majoritarian democracy", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.829375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.617375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.14, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.22525, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.016875, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.092125, "avg_liberty": 0.6307039404675172, "avg_individuality": 0.6242835132266802, "avg_integration": 0.4877903994663984, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6862308686127008, "avg_resilience": 0.40437888623051543, "avg_prosperity": 0.4140697984758686, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7154095408839887, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9126336711519488, "avg_trust": 0.5978470353707166, "avg_inequality": 0.6452853731203563, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.989281595625235, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014538954130548277, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5143949126012032, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5316374828443278, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5571088982003517, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4749601917066304, "score_Stability-first": 0.50049528887533, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5258995916648677}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Strict consociational parity", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.71875, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.572375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.431625, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.170125, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01175, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.002, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.08725, "avg_liberty": 0.6757771604923457, "avg_individuality": 0.6662628752069147, "avg_integration": 0.46501262806473326, "avg_legitimacy": 0.5706786606365535, "avg_resilience": 0.4861400337880349, "avg_prosperity": 0.3427610613346364, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8411430740387275, "avg_governance_eff": 0.6030331397890545, "avg_trust": 0.5428772689145913, "avg_inequality": 0.6336062645960316, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9922111249226676, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.009335113254622985, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5143342170740162, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5319528863214819, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5128041720487697, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.43762550495563945, "score_Stability-first": 0.4792840418589548, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5379884583449444}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Species-separated federalism", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.788375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.623375, "free_integrated_rate": 0.19325, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.181, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.012, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.0045, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.089875, "avg_liberty": 0.6902744611344523, "avg_individuality": 0.6844861173036532, "avg_integration": 0.40738165148093425, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6285985195235121, "avg_resilience": 0.5506321878012541, "avg_prosperity": 0.3762636653253511, "avg_anti_domination": 0.8620757278237892, "avg_governance_eff": 0.7580009954198265, "avg_trust": 0.5638515069707524, "avg_inequality": 0.6557272755146519, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9911651213624866, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.00995750576821508, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.5517448914801304, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.5739098957215718, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5639203269215207, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.49166353089602477, "score_Stability-first": 0.5351049616759285, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5702207340140223}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Technocratic guardian governance", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.739625, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.394125, "free_integrated_rate": 0.21075, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.416625, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.00825, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.00625, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.088, "avg_liberty": 0.5515087163513541, "avg_individuality": 0.7132444122479312, "avg_integration": 0.5415202745461666, "avg_legitimacy": 0.504691718210948, "avg_resilience": 0.6282066483676775, "avg_prosperity": 0.4018014011800956, "avg_anti_domination": 0.765781260306958, "avg_governance_eff": 0.8703579018367609, "avg_trust": 0.48971598002996075, "avg_inequality": 0.6249333426524197, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.987934367869427, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.012843133301232093, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4886908284530523, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.48209047730519955, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.4767540738324086, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.451046550831187, "score_Stability-first": 0.4899153557959575, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5035736803047774}, {"scenario": "20 Post-scarcity abundance", "architecture": "Minimal-rights market order", "n": 8000, "years": 300, "survival_rate": 0.819375, "no_catastrophic_failure": 0.569875, "free_integrated_rate": 0.23875, "domination_rate": 0.0, "authoritarian_rate": 0.271, "bifurcation_rate": 0.0, "individuality_failure_rate": 0.0, "species_loss_unrecovered_rate": 0.01675, "private_sovereignty_rate": 0.0, "conflict_ever_rate": 0.007875, "catastrophe_ever_rate": 0.092125, "avg_liberty": 0.6402659752386853, "avg_individuality": 0.641651871895008, "avg_integration": 0.46380284307056674, "avg_legitimacy": 0.6504712794173877, "avg_resilience": 0.38116771433315794, "avg_prosperity": 0.40581180963260244, "avg_anti_domination": 0.7163534702353737, "avg_governance_eff": 0.9089145833333333, "avg_trust": 0.5683311102621426, "avg_inequality": 0.6141841623898232, "avg_synth_share_final": 0.9898383256752218, "avg_rogue_share_final": 0.014155824683706825, "score_PULSE-aligned": 0.4973254149537113, "score_Classical-liberal": 0.518839899463809, "score_Procedural-democratic": 0.5349230818601848, "score_Capability-utilitarian": 0.4546413260564828, "score_Stability-first": 0.476204903335695, "score_Individuality-first": 0.5136032091603796}], "rankings": {"PULSE-aligned": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7106206896467734, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6166872348458063, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5517448914801304, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5143949126012032, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5143342170740162, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4973254149537113, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4886908284530523, "rank": 7}], "Classical-liberal": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7093504422409175, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.640097577159326, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5739098957215718, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5319528863214819, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5316374828443278, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.518839899463809, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.48209047730519955, "rank": 7}], "Procedural-democratic": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.708673678175989, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6501275422220094, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5639203269215207, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5571088982003517, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5349230818601848, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5128041720487697, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4767540738324086, "rank": 7}], "Capability-utilitarian": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6250517403934855, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5527379935718091, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.49166353089602477, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.4749601917066304, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.4546413260564828, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.451046550831187, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.43762550495563945, "rank": 7}], "Stability-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.6909920559875387, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.5894838478450911, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5351049616759285, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.50049528887533, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.4899153557959575, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.4792840418589548, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.476204903335695, "rank": 7}], "Individuality-first": [{"architecture_id": "PULSE", "score": 0.7273155030963586, "rank": 1}, {"architecture_id": "Liberal constitutional democracy", "score": 0.6341339229490124, "rank": 2}, {"architecture_id": "Species-separated federalism", "score": 0.5702207340140223, "rank": 3}, {"architecture_id": "Strict consociational parity", "score": 0.5379884583449444, "rank": 4}, {"architecture_id": "Majoritarian democracy", "score": 0.5258995916648677, "rank": 5}, {"architecture_id": "Minimal-rights market order", "score": 0.5136032091603796, "rank": 6}, {"architecture_id": "Technocratic guardian governance", "score": 0.5035736803047774, "rank": 7}]}, "interpretation": {"plain": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 72.21% of these modeled runs. Abundance is deliberately favorable on several inputs. It does not eliminate uncertainty about future personhood, preferences or political behavior.", "technical": "PULSE ranks 1 of 7 under all six value systems. Its free-and-integrated outcome occurs in 72.21% of these modeled runs. Abundance is deliberately favorable on several inputs. It does not eliminate uncertainty about future personhood, preferences or political behavior."}, "negative_results": {"metrics_below_liberal": ["survival_rate", "avg_governance_eff", "avg_prosperity"], "pulse_rank_by_value": {"PULSE-aligned": 1, "Classical-liberal": 1, "Procedural-democratic": 1, "Capability-utilitarian": 1, "Stability-first": 1, "Individuality-first": 1}}, "caveat": {"plain": "These are results inside an assumed future, not forecasts. The same project designed PULSE and assigned the model rules. Scores depend on those choices. A high score does not establish that a constitution will work in practice.", "technical": "Internally reproduced aggregate outputs from the v2 model campaign. Architecture coefficients, behavioral functions, outcome thresholds and normative weights are explicit project assumptions, not empirically fitted forecasts or independent constitutional validation."}, "source_ids": ["baseline-v2", "scenario-parameters", "model-code"]}], "sources": {"baseline-v2": {"path": "long-horizon/data/main_scenario_architecture_results_v2.csv", "sha256": "e3c2a01461d97cb6deeb2443020f8276608876da2ed84606c31a4c20b8e2edd1", "kind": "PULSE simulation"}, "scenario-parameters": {"path": "long-horizon/data/scenario_archetype_parameters.csv", "sha256": "6689bd2686db1b25749ad03ad0688279a40806b18cbadbd17302330c2b8e57e6", "kind": "PULSE simulation"}, "architecture-parameters": {"path": "long-horizon/data/architecture_parameterization.csv", "sha256": "dbf47adfeecbda8dda0931e4077e1765b964018da3159e583702c69f87a0ddc0", "kind": "PULSE simulation"}, "value-weights": {"path": "long-horizon/data/value_system_weights.csv", "sha256": "79d0e961076ea960a589d31885d12fa8c676d5436df4ecd7862be94d99f98196", "kind": "PULSE simulation"}, "model-code": {"path": "long-horizon/code/pulse_long_horizon_sim.py", "sha256": "58ff8bc5468d163e8c0be37c9b7b9b643780e88ad233e41295d4243f139c45da", "kind": "Project source"}, "verification": {"path": "long-horizon/verification.json", "sha256": "ad3155a6e8919bdb112460f6b4a716a90829925972672b4938534c73a86e8953", "kind": "Project source"}, "errata": {"path": "long-horizon/ERRATA.txt", "sha256": "5dc03334a08dc62e6e4104497e5862c6a90d2c433117731c2ab2c613371afd28", "kind": "Project source"}}}